What is the best approach for creating HTML and CSS layouts: focusing on margin/padding or positioning?

When it comes to designing with HTML5 and CSS3, is it more beneficial to rely on margin and padding for layouts or should positioning be the main focus?

I have always combined both methods to achieve desired outcomes but there are examples where each approach can be effective, as demonstrated below:

HTML

<div>
        <ul>
            <li><span>1</span></li>
            <li><span>2</span></li>
        </ul>
    </div>

CSS Example 1 - Utilizing margin and padding

div{
    width:1000px;
    margin:auto;
    }
ul{
    margin-left:10px;
    width:100px;
    }
li{
    height:30px;
    }
span{
    margin-top:10px;
    }

CSS Example 2 - Focusing solely on positioning (Except for margin:auto ..)

div, ul, span{
    position:absolute;
}   

div{
    width:1000px;
     margin:auto;
}
ul{
    left:10px;
    width:100px;
}
li{
    height:30px;
}
span{
    top:10px;
}

Answer №1

When considering a typical page layout, Example 1 stands out as the cleaner option and is recommended if you have the choice.

On the other hand, Example 2 can be problematic because once you apply position: absolute to elements, it eliminates any inherent flexibility in your design. This often requires setting specific dimensions for everything.

As a general rule (although there are exceptions), it's best to avoid using position: absolute for the main layout unless absolutely necessary.

If you're curious about the issues that can arise, check out this example link. In some cases, users may resort to using JavaScript to resolve these kinds of problems, which is not ideal.

Answer №2

Utilizing positioning can be beneficial for elements that need to stand out or those that are dynamically generated. In some cases, the placement of an element is determined by its positioning. Padding and margins play a significant role in determining how elements will be positioned in relation to one another. Therefore, an element may have padding, margins, and positioning attributes, each contributing to its overall placement.

A common approach is to consider the client's viewing environment when designing layouts.

For information on using JavaScript to determine the client screen size in a cross-browser compliant manner, refer to this link:

Answer №3

Typically, position rules are considered the most appropriate choice, given their name implies so.

margins can be unreliable due to inconsistencies in their models across different browsers, making them less ideal for certain purposes.

However, many layout techniques combine elements of both position and margin, using them together in a complementary manner.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Creating word spacing in CSS paired with a navigation menu using Dreamweaver

As a beginner in Dreamweaver, CSS, and HTML, I may have made some mistakes or overlooked simple solutions. I am currently struggling with how to separate words in my navigation menu, as they always appear centered. Despite trying adjustments like "word-spa ...

Is it possible for me to create a CSS class based on a condition using [ngCLASS]?

I am struggling with logic writing in my Angular2 project. On a HTML page, I have two buttons - YES and NO that I want to style with different colors. I have set up a condition in the div tag like this: ngClass="'result'?'yes':' ...

Customize the Position of Icons in Material UI

I am looking for guidance on how to position my components within an image using Material UI. Specifically, I want to move my heart component to the top right corner of the image and place the ratings at the bottom. import image from "../../Assets/pic ...

What is the best way to create a transparent sticky header that blends with the background while still maintaining visibility over images and text?

On my web page, the background features a radial gradient but the content extends beyond the viewport, causing the center of the gradient to not align with the center of the screen, producing the desired effect. However, I'm facing an issue with a sti ...

Potential image positioned to the left of a detailed description

A Meteor client template helper contains an array of objects {image: url, label: description}. The URL can either point to a valid image file in the public directory or be the string 'non'. The description can range from a few words to several ...

Unable to transfer HTML code into the TinyMCE editor

I've successfully stored raw HTML content in my database, and now I want to display it in my TinyMCE editor for users to easily edit and submit. Below is the form: <textarea id="postfullOnEditPop" type="text" class="validate" placeholder="Enter f ...

JavaScript and Responsive Design Techniques

I'm struggling to create a responsive page that starts with a mobile-first approach, but I keep running into the same issue. When I have my dropdown menu in the mobile version, it looks good. However, when I try to switch it to the non-mobile version ...

What is the method for toggling background URLs?

Currently, I am utilizing flaunt.js by Todd Moto for my navigation system. My goal is to seamlessly switch the hamburger image with another image when the mobile-menu is shown and hidden. Check out the demo here. For a detailed tutorial, visit this link. ...

Customize Swiper js: How to adjust the Gap Size Between Slides using rem, em, or %?

Is there a way to adjust the spacing between slides in Swiper js using relative units such as 2rem? The entire page is designed with relative units. All measurements are set in rem, which adjusts based on the viewport size for optimal adaptability. For i ...

Combining selected boxes through merging

Looking to create a simple webpage with the following requirements: There should be 10 rows and 3 boxes in each row. If I select 2 or more boxes or drag a box, they should merge together. For example, if my initial screen looks like this: and then I se ...

Ways to display a specific section on an HTML page using AngularJS

Main page content <div class="row"> <div class="col-md-3"> link 1 link 2 link 3 . . . </div> </div> <div class="col-md-9"> <div ng-view></div> </div& ...

Chrome stack router outlet and the utilization of the Angular back button

I'm experiencing an issue with the back button on Chrome while using Angular 14. When I return to a previous page (URL), instead of deleting the current page components, it keeps adding more and more as I continue to press the back button (the deeper ...

Website route organization tool

Seeking assistance with implementing a route planning feature on my website. The user should be presented with multiple route options upon entering their origin and destination. Take a look at this reference site for inspiration: Any help would be great ...

Exploring the methods of connecting with data-checked and data-unchecked attributes in Angular

Utilizing a toggle switch, I am able to determine what text to display in the div by utilizing html attributes such as data-checked and data-unchecked. In addition, I have an Angular pipe that translates all texts on the website based on the selected lang ...

Modify the background color of four results with the help of PHP

With php, I am looking to dynamically change the background color of a td based on the number within it. While this can be achieved using CSS by assigning different classes to each td with specific colors, I prefer a more straightforward method for mainten ...

Siblings selectors within Internet Explorer slow down significantly when using the :hover pseudo-class

Sample page: http://jsfiddle.net/y2pwqch6/6/ This particular example showcases a CSS selector known as the adjacent sibling selector: .l:hover + .r { color: blue } The issue arises when hovering over any element on the page, causing Internet Explore ...

Efficiently Minimize Bootstrap Components Upon Clicking the Link

I've successfully created a navigation menu that expands and collapses without using a dropdown feature. However, I'm encountering an issue where I can't seem to toggle the div when clicking on a menu link. I attempted to use JavaScript to c ...

Ways to resolve the issue of being unable to retrieve data using jQuery

My code is working, but I am facing a little annoying problem that I can't solve on my own. The problem is that I can only retrieve the first record (id) from my data grid, but I can't retrieve the second or any other record id. For example: W ...

What is causing the error message stating that the DateTime class object cannot be converted to a string?

I found this code snippet on a programming forum function increaseDate($date_str, ${ $date = new DateTime($date_str); $start_day = $date->format('j'); $date->modify("+{$months} month"); $end_day = $date->format(&apo ...

MUI: Issue with pseudo element appearing cropped outside of Paper container

I am facing an issue where a red arrow pseudo element '::before' is partially cut off outside its container '.MuiPaper-root'. I need the arrow to remain visible, any suggestions on how to fix this? Here is the relevant code snippet and ...