Compel the browser to initiate a reflow by adjusting the CSS

I am currently in the process of building a responsive image slider without relying on jQuery, using CSS3 transitions.

The setup is quite simple: there's a viewport with a UL inside, containing relatively positioned LIs that are left floated.

However, I've encountered an issue in this scenario:

  1. When the user clicks the "prev" arrow,
  2. JS adds the appropriate LI before the one currently displayed.
  3. At this point, the UL has its CSS transition set to none 0s linear to avoid sudden animations. At this stage, I decrease the UL's CSS left value by the width of the slider (for example: from 0px to -1200px) to maintain consistency in view.
  4. Then, I change the UL's transition property to all 0.2s ease-out.
  5. Finally, I adjust the UL's left property to initiate the CSS3 animation (e.g., from -1200px to 0px).

The problem arises when the browser simplifies these changes and fails to execute any animations.

Stoyan Stefanov discussed the reflow problem in depth on his blog here, but attempting to force a reflow on the element doesn't seem to resolve it.

Below is a snippet of code illustrating this issue (omitting browser prefixes for clarity):

ul.style.transition = 'none 0s linear 0s';
ul.style.left = '-600px';
ul.style.transition = 'all 0.2s ease-out';
ul.style.left = '0px';

To witness the problem in action, you can visit this fiddle: http://jsfiddle.net/9WX5b/1/

Answer №1

When you need to get the offsetHeight of an element and trigger a reflow, there is a handy function that can help with that:

function forceReflow(element){
    console.log(element.offsetHeight);
}

You can use this function in situations where reflows are necessary. Check out this example: http://jsfiddle.net/9WX5b/2/

UPDATE: I recently came across the need for this and started looking for a more efficient way than just using console.log. Simply referencing element.offsetHeight as a standalone statement may not force a reflow due to optimization by browsers like Chrome, since it's seen as accessing a property without a specified getter. As far as I know, the most cost-effective method to achieve this is using void(element.offsetHeight), since it introduces some uncertainty that the void operator may have side effects or could be overridden in some cases (but I'm not entirely sure).

Answer №2

function reflowComponent( target ) {
    if ( target === undefined ) {
        target = document.documentElement;
    }
    void( target.offsetHeight );
}

This function is compatible with Chrome and FF, and currently appears to be the most straightforward and widely applicable method available.

Answer №3

While the information has already been shared in the comments of other answers, here is a comprehensive list of triggers. It's important to note that for getters like elem.offsetWidth, wrapping it in a function call is unnecessary. The getter will be invoked regardless, and bypassing it could lead to serious issues if an optimization attempt were made.

Reflow should be used judiciously as it can have negative repercussions if misused.


To grasp the concept of reflow and its necessity in this context, I recommend reading through this answer along with related responses. In essence, the browser delays recalculating CSSOM boxes and styles until the last moment, thus only recognizing the final state when a transition is applied while overlooking any temporary removals. Initiating a synchronous reflow compels the CSSOM to reassess all page elements, acknowledging the absence of the transition set initially, thereby preparing for its subsequent application.

A reflow entails recalculating all document elements, which can significantly burden computational resources. When used iteratively or within intricate DOM layouts, it may severely impact overall page performance.

For transitioning effects, leverage the Web Animations API

This API, though absent in 2014, has been supported across modern browsers for years now. By interfacing directly with the animation engine where CSSOM manages animations and transitions, the Web Animations API eliminates the need for convoluted DOM manipulation pathways.
This method streamlines style recalculations, offers JavaScript-friendly functionalities, and provides clear Promises for smooth event handling, surpassing the complexities associated with numerous CSS animation-x events.

To replicate OP's fiddle using the Web Animations API, follow these simple steps:

function makeAnimation()
{
    const ul = document.getElementsByTagName('ul')[0];
    ul.animate(
      [ // Keyframes defining the animation/transition
        { left: "-600px", },
        { left: "-0px", }
      ],
      { duration: 200/* ms */, easing: "ease-out" }
    );
}
.viewport { width: 600px; height: 300px; }
ul { list-style: none; margin: 0; padding: 0; position: relative; width: 250%;  }
ul li { display: block; float: left; width: 600px; height: 300px; line-height: 300px; font-size: 30px; text-align: center; }
<div class="viewport">
    <ul>
        <li style="background: lightblue; color: red">1</li>
        <li style="background:gray; color: black;">2</li>
    </ul>
</div>
<button onclick="makeAnimation()">Make animation</button>


If triggering a reflow becomes imperative...

Although this topic warrants a separate Q/A session, consolidating all reflow triggers into a single phase and ensuring no interference with the box model is crucial. This demands meticulous control over DOM modifications to prevent disruptions. Essentially, during any point in the Event-Loop sequence, refrain from invoking any triggers (as some can be stealthy) after making your intended adjustments to the DOM.
Instead, await the subsequent ResizeObserver callback. These callbacks execute post-browser recalculation (specs, step 16), meaning that by delaying until this stage and then calling elem.offsetWidth, the browser caches the data, eliminating the need for further recalculation & reflows. However, maintaining DOM integrity throughout this process is paramount. A viable approach involves employing a two-phase handler within ResizeObserver callbacks—initially gathering computed values followed by executing DOM manipulations based on these computations.

This approach typically limits reflows to just two per frame (one triggered by the browser and one by custom scripts). Even with thorough knowledge of reflow triggers, unexpected occurrences like those induced by scrollTo(), which combines reflow initiation with box alterations beyond user intervention, can pose challenges...

Answer №4

requestAnimationFrame is recommended for most scenarios and provides a cleaner approach compared to relying on undocumented side effects of DOM APIs:

element.style.transition = 'none';
requestAnimationFrame(() => {
  element.style.transition = 'all 1s ease';
});

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Storing a reference to children generated by a function within a child prop

I am currently working on a Feed component that accepts a data prop, consisting of an array of items, and a children prop intended for a function that maps the data to a DOM element. My current challenge is implementing the ability to scroll to any elemen ...

Ways to refresh UI in ReactJS without triggering a specific event

In my React application, I am displaying various pictures and GIFs that users can attach to a post. Currently, each image has an onClick handler which triggers either a modal with different options or deletes the picture if the user holds down the ctrl key ...

Using importXML with Internet Explorer 11

My project website includes a roster page that retrieves XML data. Previously, this functionality worked across all browsers but now it only works in Chrome. In IE11, it seems that the importXML function is not functioning correctly as the roster data is m ...

Implement safe instructions through communication between the client and server

I am currently using Fancy WebSockets in Javascript for communication with my php server to support my multiplayer game. At the moment, I am simply sending raw sockets (json) as Sending: {"command": "login", "data": {"id" : "1575","md5" : "6bd8937a8789a3 ...

Enhancing data rendering by incorporating extra verifications through the logical AND operator to prevent crashes upon page refresh

Upon refreshing the page, my app crashed. The issue stemmed from the page loading faster than my data, prompting me to include additional checks using the logical AND operator. While effective in preventing crashes, this approach seems laborious and begs t ...

Utilizing PUG for Iterating Through Multiple Items in Express Framework using JSON Data

I'm currently working on a small application using Express and PUG, aiming to achieve the following: https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZDyTK.png index.pug ul#restaurants-list li img.restaurant-img(alt='Mission Chinese Food', sr ...

Utilizing cookies to track the read status of articles - markers for reference

Currently, I am in the process of developing a website and am interested in implementing a feature that allows users to track which articles they have read. I am considering adding a small circle next to each article heading to signify whether it has been ...

After incorporating an additional element, the li:nth-child(odd) selector is no longer functioning correctly

I previously had a setup where items in a list would have alternate colors using jQuery: $('ul.follows li:nth-child(odd)').addClass('alternate'); Everything was functioning properly until I introduced an a tag before the list items. N ...

Struggling to convert my VueJS component from JavaScript to TypeScript, feeling a bit lost

I am new to VueJS and I am facing a challenge converting my VueJS project to use TypeScript. I have been trying to bind functions to certain variables in JavaScript, but I am struggling with accomplishing the same in TypeScript. Even though there are no er ...

Dynamic value changes in AngularJS checkboxes controlled by ng-model within controller

I have a page that loads data from a database and displays it in a grid. It has a button to manually refresh the data, as well as a checkbox for automatic refreshing. Below is the HTML code: <div id="TestViewTable" ng-controller="testTableManager" ng- ...

Retrieve information from Angular service's HTTP response

Calling all Angular/Javascript aficionados! I need some help with a service that makes API calls to fetch data: app.service("GetDivision", ["$http", function($http){ this.division = function(divisionNumber){ $http.post("/api/division", {division:di ...

Select the correct nested div with the same name by clicking on it

My problem involves nested div elements with the same class. For example, I have a Panel inside another Panel. However, when I click on the inner panel, it is actually the outer panel that triggers the $(".panel").click function. What I need is for the ...

vue-router incorrectly updates parameters upon reload

One question I have is related to routing in Vue.js: // routes.js { path: '/posts', name: 'Posts', component: PostsView }, { path: '/post/:post_id', name: 'PostRead', component: PostReadView, }, { pat ...

Utilizing Fullcalendar Qtip to display information on mouseover rather than utilizing the eventRender

I have a challenge with integrating Qtip to the eventMousever event instead of the eventRender event in fullcalendar. The main reason for this adjustment is due to the server hosting the data being located in another country, resulting in significant late ...

Can you show me the way to open a single card?

Can someone assist me in making it so only one card opens when clicked, rather than all of them opening at once? Additionally, if there is already an open card and I click on another one, the currently open card should close automatically. If you have any ...

How can I run a TypeScript function within a JavaScript file?

I am working with a typescript file named file1.ts export function Hello(str: string) { console.log(str); } In addition, I have another file called index.js { require('./some.js'); } Furthermore, there is a script defined in the pack ...

Use two separate AJAX requests to open and close the modal dialog

I am experiencing an issue with my subscription form that uses modal windows. After closing the window and trying to subscribe again, the ajax calls are being duplicated, resulting in an error. $("#openModal").click(function() { if($("#wname").val() = ...

Assign a CSS class to a DIV depending on the vertical position of the cursor

The website I am currently developing is located at Within the site, there is a collection of project titles. When hovering over a project title, the featured image is displayed directly below it. I would like to change the positioning of these images to ...

I am in search of a container that has full height, along with unique footer and content characteristics

I have set up a jsfiddle to demonstrate the scenario I am facing: There is a basic header, content, footer layout. Within the content-container is a messenger that should expand to a maximum of 100% height. Beyond 100% height, it should become scrollable. ...

Navigate to the end of a container

Is there a method to automatically scroll to the bottom of a div when the page is loaded? I have attempted several solutions without success. If you have any insights, please share them. Thank you! ...