When should CSS compression and combining / JS minification be performed - at runtime or during build time?

I need to find a way to compress, version (for caching reasons), and possibly combine our JS and CSS files. I've come across two main approaches so far:

1) During the build process: Using an MSBuild task or similar. 2) Dynamically at runtime: Through a custom HTTPHandler (we are using ASP.NET), where something like the following would be included in your pages:

<link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="~/StyleSheetHandler.ashx?stylesheets=~stylesheets/master.css" />

Can anyone provide insights into the pros and cons of each method? Personally, I don't see the benefit of doing it dynamically and consuming CPU resources with each request (even if it's only done once and cached afterwards), but am I overlooking something?

Thank you! Mark.

asp.netjavascriptcsscachingcompression

Answer №1

In my opinion, it is wise to implement various compression strategies based on the environment:

  • Avoid compression during development (ideal for coding and debugging)
  • Runtime compression for testing environments (offers flexibility without sacrificing performance)
  • Buildtime compression for both staging and production (ensures reliability and optimized performance)

Personally, I have utilized the YUI compressor for compressing Javascript and CSS, emphasizing the importance of testing minified files.

Incorporating static minified JS and CSS files as part of the production build presents several advantages:

  • Thoroughly tested content
  • Efficient serving without ASP.NET overhead
  • Potential for browser caching
  • Enhanced webserver-gzip support

Answer №2

Avoiding compression altogether is the most effective approach, as modern browsers and servers already support Gzip encoding. Consider the following statistics:

  • cfform.js - 21k
  • cfform-minified.js - 12k
  • cfform.js.gz - 4.2k
  • cfform-minified.js.gz - 2.2k

Although this JS file contains unnecessary whitespace, the overall savings amount to a mere 2k. Additionally, these savings are per-visitor due to caching, rather than per-page. Is the effort truly worth it for such minimal gains?

Cutting a pixel width from your banner would yield tenfold greater savings, especially considering that 99% of users have broadband connections. This minute reduction in download time hardly warrants celebration.

Furthermore, JS compression imposes the added task of decompression on every page load for clients, with equally underwhelming savings post-Gzip compression.

In all seriousness, the complications and debugging associated with compression are unjustifiable unless specifically catering to a mobile audience or handling an immense daily traffic volume. Otherwise, it's best to simply forego compression efforts altogether.

Answer №3

In my opinion, it is more efficient to handle it on the initial request and then cache it. This approach allows for easy updates to the CSS in a clear and organized manner without the need to constantly rebuild. By basing the cache on the CSS file, any changes made will automatically trigger a refresh of the cache.

Regards, Emma

Answer №4

Performing tasks at runtime only when necessary provides the highest level of flexibility. This can be a concern with PHP as it lacks a build step, so adding unnecessary steps should be avoided. However, this concern applies to other platforms as well

For more information on optimizing JavaScript and CSS in PHP, consider reading articles such as Supercharging Javascript in PHP and Supercharging CSS in PHP. While the examples are specific to PHP, the concepts discussed are universal for any Web platform.

Answer №5

In my opinion, creating it at runtime is the way to go unless your CSS and JS files are exceptionally large (over 1MB). To clear the browser cache, you can set specific HTTP headers. If you need the application to trigger a reload on the client side, simply modify an HTTP parameter:

<link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="~/StyleSheetHandler.ashx?stylesheets=~stylesheets/master.css&token=2" />

Adjusting the token will prompt the CSS to refresh on the client side.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Automatically close the multiselect dropdown when the user interacts outside of it (varied scenario)

For those interested, check out this jsfiddle link: http://jsfiddle.net/jaredwilli/vUSPu/ This specific code snippet focuses on creating a multi-select dropdown feature. When a user chooses options from the dropdown and then clicks outside of the menu are ...

javascriptjquerycssangularjs

Experiencing erratic outcomes with window.innerWidth in Mobile Safari

I am currently using JavaScript to determine the width of the browser: $(document).ready(function(){ var width = window.innerWidth; }); However, it seems that this method is producing inconsistent results. To showcase the issue, I have created a fun ...

javascriptjquerymobile-safari

Executing multiple ajax calls and retrieving the results: A step-by-step guide

I am looking to run a series of Ajax calls and collect the responses before rendering the results for the user. The current code I am using is not working as expected because the render function is being executed before all the Ajax responses have been ga ...

javascriptjqueryajax

Discover the method to determine the total count of days in a given week number

I am developing a gantt chart feature that allows users to select a start date and an end date. The gantt chart should display the week numbers in accordance with the ISO standard. However, I have encountered two situations where either the start week numb ...

javascriptangulartypescript

Generating an associative array on the fly

I am interested in transforming a hash by creating nested keys and then adding another hash at the end. For example... var hash_a = {'foo': 'bar'} var hash_b = {'alpha': 'beta'} var array = ['a', 'b& ...

javascriptnode.jsassociative-array

Looking for assistance in streamlining my jQuery code for bootstrap tab pane. Any takers?

Having trouble setting a specific tab as active when navigating from different links. I have found a solution, but it involves writing code for each individual tab. Can someone offer assistance in simplifying the code? <table class="nav nav-tabs"> ...

jqueryhtmlcsstwitter-bootstrap

Tips for creating a smooth scrolling header menu on a standard header

<script> $(document).ready(function(){ $(".nav-menu").click(function(e){ e.preventDefault(); id = $(this).data('id'); $('html, body').animate({ scrollTop: $("#"+id).o ...

javascripthtmljquery

Utilize CSS to selectively target specific sections of a repetitive pattern within a list

I have come across a list fragment that is generated automatically and I only have the ability to adjust the CSS for it. <ul class="menu"> <li class=" menuItem1 first parent"></li> <li class=" menuItem2 parent"></li> ...

htmlcss

Tips on effectively managing an XMLhttp request to a PHP controller

Encountering an internal server error and nothing is being logged in the PHP error log. This issue persists despite not using any frameworks. DEV - controllers |-> user -> check_email.php - public_html |-> routes ...

javascriptphpajax

Flag is to be set while moving through the input fields

I am currently working on a form with multiple text fields and a text area. I have implemented a loop to go through each of these fields and check if there is a value present. If the field is empty, I set a flag to pass=false. On the other hand, if a value ...

javascriptjquery

Verify the status of the internet button and display a message indicating whether it has been selected or not

I’ve been attempting to complete this task: opening this particular page in Python, and observing the outcome when the "Remote eligible" button is enabled; do any job positions appear or not? Here's the code I have so far, but it keeps throwing thi ...

pythonhtmlcssselenium-webdriverweb-scraping

Vue.js does not receive the MQTT response message

I am a beginner with Vue and I'm currently working on a project where I need to set a default value for Vue data return(). Right now, when the code runs, it logs console.log('INSIDE CLIENT ON MESSAGE"). However, the value defined as this.roo ...

javascriptvue.jsvuejs2vue-componentmqtt

Ways to center a spinner on the screen using CSS during loading

Upon loading the page, my spinner appears in the center of the screen after a second. However, in the initial frame of the page, it is not centered but positioned on the top-left corner instead. How can I ensure that my spinner starts off centered from the ...

htmlcssangulargif

Arranging a div's position in relation to an unrelated div

I need to position a div element called "a" below another div element known as "b". The HTML code has the following structure: <div id="a"></div> <form> <div id="b"></div> <div id="c"></div> </form> U ...

css

Switch images when hovering

I currently have two dropdown menus called NEW and SHOP. When I hover over the New Menu 1, it should display the corresponding image. Similarly, when hovering over New Menu 2, the related image should be shown in a div with the ".menu-viewer" class. Whil ...

jquerycss

What mistakes did I make in my Ajax code?

My aim is to dynamically add items to my listbox when a button is clicked, and then retrieve the value of the added item in the listbox using ajax. Below is the code I have tried: $('#right').click(function () { alert("Start process"); ...

javascriptc#jqueryajax

tips for aligning figcaption vertically to image within figure

Is there a way to vertically align the text in the figcaption with the image in this figure? Check out an example here: http://jsfiddle.net/YdATG/1/ Here is the HTML code: <section class="links"> <a href="#"> <figure class="grid-pa ...

htmlcssimagealignmentfigure

Eliminate extraneous space with the clearfix:after pseudo-element

Could use some help figuring out how to remove the unwanted whitespace caused by clearing the float (specifically after the tabs). Any suggestions on how to fix this issue? Take a look at the code snippet below (jsfiddle): /* Clearfix */ .clearfix:af ...

jqueryhtmlcss

Utilize Typescript to aim for the most recent edition of EcmaScript

Are you looking to configure your typescript build to compile to the most recent version or the most current stable release of EcmaScript? For example, using this command: tsc --target <get latest version> Alternatively, in a tsconfig file: { & ...

javascriptnode.jstypescriptecmascript-6tsconfig

Is it optimal to count negative indexes in JavaScript arrays towards the total array length?

When working in JavaScript, I typically define an array like this: var arr = [1,2,3]; It's also possible to do something like: arr[-1] = 4; However, if I were to then set arr to undefined using: arr = undefined; I lose reference to the value at ...

javascriptarrays