What is the most effective method for customizing non-MUI elements within an MUI framework?

As someone new to React and development in general, I understand that there are various ways to style elements within React itself:

  • importing CSS,
  • using locally scoped CSS modules,
  • implementing CSS-in-JS via libraries like Styled Components or Emotion,
  • utilizing utility-first CSS frameworks such as Tailwind,
  • employing extracted CSS with tools like "Compiled" and "Linaria",
  • applying inline styling,
  • or using style object variables.

In addition, there are currently two APIs available for styling MUI (Material-UI) elements:

  • Styled API
  • SX API

When it comes to customizing MUI components, it is recommended to choose one of these options; however, it does not necessarily mean excluding other non-MUI styling techniques.

Therefore, the question arises: what is the best practice, or at least a suitable practice, for minimizing the number of styling methods used to avoid bloated code?

This leads to further inquiries that are not explicitly addressed in the documentation:

  • What sets apart MUI's styled API from standard "styled components" (CSS-in-JS via emotion)?
  • Are there any conflicts between React's styling approaches and MUI APIs?
  • Are there any styling techniques that clash with MUI styling APIs?
  • If non-MUI elements should not be styled with MUI APIs, is it advisable to stick to a single preferred method while keeping it minimal?
  • Regardless of the chosen approach, are there scenarios where it cannot be solely relied upon?

For instance, consider a scenario where I need to work with a non-MUI component: specifically, attempting to center an SVG that may vary in width and height dynamically. The goal is to ensure that it always fits the screen without triggering scroll bars by adjusting its dimensions accordingly.

Answer №1

According to a response on reddit, it appears that there are no conflicting issues between the styling methods of React and MUI. The key is to ensure that the specificity order of your styles is set up as desired. In larger codebases, consistency in styling, even when using MUI, is recommended. There may be instances where you need to style non-MUI components separately, for which you can utilize MUI's styled() function, css-in-js, SASS, or LESS. Ultimately, there is no one-size-fits-all solution - factors such as readability, maintainability, and performance should guide your decision-making process. Considering that MUI's styled() can be used for all non-MUI elements, it would be advisable to go with that approach.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Is there a way to incorporate text at the end of a row in HTML?

I have a photo and some text on my website. The photo is displayed on the left side, while the text appears nicely on the right side. Now, I am looking to include an additional block of text below the existing text. How can I accomplish this? What steps ...

Setting elements relative to a div can be achieved by using CSS positioning properties

I'm currently learning HTML/CSS and facing a challenge in setting elements relative to a container. After reading about the differences between "relative" and "absolute" positioning, I understand that "relative" positions an element relative to where ...

Error: 'window not defined' or 'document not defined' encountered while importing a module in Next.js

I'm working on integrating a Wysiwyg editor into my web application. However, I encountered an error when trying to import the editor module. I tried using both react-draft-wysiwyg and react-quill. The former resulted in a "window not defined" error, ...

Access the properties of a child component function in Enzyme tests

Can I access the show props of the Child component using Enzyme in React? const [show] = useState(true) <Parent> <Child show={show} /> </Parent> Both the Parent and Child components are functional components. ...

How to target the last child in Flexbox using CSS order property

Is there a way to correctly detect the last child after rearranging divs using flex order? Even though I have set the order in the CSS, it is still recognizing the last child based on the DOM tree. Since the items are dynamic, we can't rely on nth-chi ...

Choose a child element with Inline styling within the Material UI makeStyles feature

Having trouble selecting a child element from style.js using material ui makeStyles for styling. style.css .item:hover > .subListItem { display: block; } The problem persists even after trying inline styling. style.js item: { "&:hover &g ...

Retrieve data from the redux store within the components nested under redux-simple-router

I am currently working on finding a way to access the redux store within a route in order to dispatch actions directly from that location. Below is an example of how my main Component is structured: class App extends Component { render() { return ( ...

What is the best way to calculate the width for each of the three elements in a row so that they all have 300px

Creating my own framework using flexbox has been an interesting journey. One of the major challenges I faced with flexbox is when dealing with an odd number of elements in a row, such as 3, 5, or 7. To tackle this issue, I decided to use JavaScript/jQuery. ...

The dividers flicker in and out of view

I have a menu with 7 elements, where clicking on an element causes its content to appear by fading in. If another element is clicked, the current content fades out and the new content fades in. I've successfully implemented this concept for 3 of the 7 ...

I would like to split a string of characters using spaces XY XYZ XYZ

As a young developer, I am facing a challenge and seeking a solution. The user enters a number in a format like XX XXX XXXX, but I need it to be separated differently. Currently, the numbers are being grouped as XXX XXX XXX, which is not the desired outp ...

Is it possible to conditionally trigger useLazyQuery in RTK Query?

Is it possible to obtain trigger from useLazyQuery conditionally? const [trigger] = props.useLazySearchQuery(); My objective is to retrieve trigger only when useLazySearchQuery is provided in the props. One way I can achieve this is by using const [ ...

What is the process for adjusting the borderColor on the Paper element in material-ui for react?

I am currently utilizing react in conjunction with material-ui. While working with material-ui, I have been attempting to customize the Paper component by adding a green borderColor. Below is my attempted code: <Paper style={{ padding: 50, }} ...

Creating unique border-radius for each point in a Highcharts column chart with React

Let's flip the script and start at the finish line. My goal is to customize my column chart to resemble this design: https://i.stack.imgur.com/FckJB.png Creating this style is a breeze with chart.js Credit: I've already delved into this inquiry ...

Question about transparency - HTML, CSS, and Bootstrap

I adjusted the opacity of the bootstrap card to 0.8, but now I want the table to be opaque while the rest of the card remains translucent. How can I achieve this effect? I attempted to add the style opacity : 1 to the table, but it didn't have the des ...

Activate browser scrollbar functionality

Below is the HTML code snippet: <html> <head> <style> #parent { position : absolute; width : 500px; height : 500px; } #top { position : absolute; width : 100%; height: 100%; z-index : 5; } #bottom { position : absolute; width : 100%; ...

What are the limitations preventing C++ applications from generating interfaces similar to those of PHP, HTML, and CSS?

I've always been puzzled by the fact that programming languages such as C++, Python, C, and others seem to be stuck in the realm of the command line. When building websites, I can easily use HTML, CSS, and PHP to quickly create both the logic and inte ...

Eliminate gaps created by grid rows by incorporating elements of varying heights

This is the standard format of the page: * { margin: 0; padding: 0; } img { width: 100%; float: left; } #grid { display: grid; grid-template-columns: repeat(3, 1fr); } #test-one { grid-column-start: 1; grid-column-end: 2; width: 100 ...

Applying padding to an absolute div inside a Bootstrap 4 parent container does not function correctly

I'm trying to create a div with absolute position inside of another div with relative position using Bootstrap 4 like this: .p-r{ padding:8px; background-color:#ddd; height:100px; } .p-a{ bottom:3px; background-color:#000 } <link re ...

What is the method for defining the initial number of rows per page in material-react-table?

I am having trouble adjusting the default number of rows per page in material-react-table. Despite following the instructions in the documentation to customize the rowsPerPage options, the initial rows per page setting remains fixed at 10 even after remov ...

Tips for keeping images stationary while expanding on hover

Currently, I am in the process of developing my first website. My main goal is to create an image gallery that displays thumbnails of images and expands them when you hover over each one. Initially, I adjusted the sizes of the images to 100px*100px using H ...