Understanding the behavior of block elements in HTML

I have a pair of section elements identified as container1 and container2 respectively. Both contain a ul element as their first child. The section with the id container1 has a border.

  • When a margin is applied to the ul elements, in the case of section#container1 (with a border), the margin appears inside the container. However, for section#container2 where there are no children before the ul element, the margin is outside the container.
  • This phenomenon occurs with any first child of a parent when the parent's dimensions are not specified.

Here is the link to the jsbin page. And here is the screenshot of the page.

  1. If the height or width of a parent block element is not defined, any margin set for the first child is treated as if it were set for the parent itself.

  2. However, when a border is present, the margin is placed inside the parent container causing it to expand. Why does this happen?

I am seeking an explanation for this behavior regarding block elements. While I acknowledge that this is fundamental, it is important to understand such intricacies.

If anyone could provide insights on this matter or direct me to resources explaining such nuances, it would be greatly appreciated. There are numerous subtle behaviors like this one that are often overlooked in tutorials. If you have discovered similar details while working on web development projects, feel free to share them in the comments or answers. Such information can be invaluable for those new to the field.

Answer №1

It appears that you are encountering a phenomenon known as "collapsing margins". A key principle of collapsing margins is that the top and bottom margins of a first child element will not create additional space between the child and its container, but instead the margin will extend beyond the container itself. This behavior is inherent to CSS and can be addressed by applying certain modifications to the container:

  • Include a border
  • Apply padding
  • Use overflow: auto

To delve deeper into this topic, check out the following resource: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/CSS/CSS_Box_Model/Mastering_margin_collapsing

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

What is the best way to create multiple PDF pages using mpdf1?

Currently using mpdf1 and looking to generate a PDF with a table of 4000 rows. Any suggestions on how to achieve this using mpdf1? Is there a method to speed up the process and avoid waiting for several minutes? ...

css failing to load properly following javascript redirection

Upon clicking the button labeled id=cancel, the user will be directed to index.php. $('#cancel').click(function() { if(changes > 0){ $('#dialog-confirm').dialog('open'); }else{ window.location.href = ". ...

What could be causing the bootstrap 4 col-md-3 block to shrink when using position fixed?

When working with Bootstrap 4, I encountered an issue where changing the block position from relative to fixed using a script caused the block to decrease in size. The script I used includes a .sticky class: .sticky { position: fixed !important; top: ...

Create a background for a dropdown list that appears unreachable, positioned above all other elements

I am encountering an issue with my autocomplete function where the drop down list appears unreadable as it is overlapping other elements on the page. The problem lies in the fact that I did not manually create the drop down list, but rather it is generate ...

CSS exhibiting variations on similar pages

Although the pages look identical, they are actually pulled from the same template file in Drupal but have different URLs. nyc.thedelimagazine.com/snacks In my document head, I've included a style rule that overrides a stylesheet further up the casc ...

Multiple occurrences of IP addresses in MySQL

Looking for assistance. I have categories and comments stored with IP addresses. I need to validate all categories for repeated IPs. For each user who uses the same IP twice, add a CSS class (red) to their name. If they use it three times, add another CSS ...

How can I ensure that my background image always stretches to full width, no matter how small the site format becomes in CSS?

I'm currently working on making my website responsive, but I'm encountering an issue. When the website width gets smaller, the background doesn't take up the full width as intended. I've tried various methods to address this problem, bu ...

<a href> hyperlink with the web address as the anchor text

Can a hyperlink be generated using a variable instead of typing in static text like CLICK HERE, so that it displays the full URL of the page specified in the a href tag, regardless of the URL? < a href="http://sourceforge.net/projects/tcpick/,">CL ...

dropdown menu items with jQuery toggle feature

Having an issue with a jQuery dropdown menu. Below is the code: $('.item-active, .item').click(function() { $(this).toggleClass('item-active'); if($('h3').hasClass('item-active')) { $(this).siblings ...

Issue with Div element not appearing on Azure AD B2C page customization

Utilizing PopperJS, I attempted to incorporate a popover box that appears when the user focuses on the password field within an Azure AD B2C page customization. Despite noticing the presence of the box element, it fails to display as intended. Any assistan ...

Deciphering image coordinates provided for incorporating an animated image component into a form

Is there a way to store the X:Y coordinates of a user click on an animated image by examining the php $_POST array? My issue is that I am able to retrieve input submission data from static images, but not from the animated one. Below is the full HTML page ...

Revealing non-div elements with the CSS hover attribute

I'm looking for a way to utilize the CSS hover property on individual elements within a div in order to affect specific span elements. For example, hovering over "something1" should reveal "text1" and so forth. Is there a way to achieve this without ...

Tips for aligning content at the bottom center of a design

Could you assist me in positioning the buttons at the bottom center of the horizontal layout as depicted in the image below? Ps: the vertical layout at the top has a dynamic height. My HTML code is as follows: <html> <body> <div class="c ...

Incorporating a search bar into a container in WordPress

I was trying to include a search form inside a div using the code below: printf( '<div class="entry"><p>%s</p>%s</div>', apply_filters( 'genesis_noposts_text', __( 'Try again below.', 'genesis&apo ...

The conditional statement of either/or

I need to create a button that changes based on whether checkboxes are checked. If none are checked, I want to show a disabled button. If one or more are checked, I want to display a different button. JavaScript $("#checkAll").change(function ( ...

Links have a longer transition delay compared to the content

In a unique JavaScript function I've developed, the my-content-section-visible class is removed and replaced with my-content-section-hidden. This change is being made to hide a particular div using a smooth transition effect. The transition itself is ...

Troubles encountered in retrieving values from various <select>/<option> elements

Having some trouble with the code below. I am attempting to retrieve the values of the selected options from my layout_select2. Currently, when I select 'multi_select' and then an option from 'layout_select2', I end up with the first v ...

What is the best way to use Bootstrap to position form input at the bottom of a page?

Does anyone have any tips on aligning a bootstrap form input to the bottom of the page? I've tried a few different methods but haven't had any luck. Here's how it looks currently. And here's how I'd like it to look. I'm aim ...

Angular ng-repeat can sometimes lead to annoying flickering on the webpage

I have a code snippet that displays a list of thumbnails: <div class ="channel" ng-repeat ="channel in UIModel.channels" ng-class ="{evenchannel: ($index % 2) == 0, oddchannel: ($index % 2) == 1}"> <img class="channel-img" ng-src ="da ...

Owl carousel experiencing issues with navigating to the previous and next slides

I've been struggling to get the owl carousel slider working properly, specifically the previous and next buttons. Here is a snippet of my code: <div class="magazine-carousel owl-theme"> <div class="item"></div> <div class="item" ...