Is the order of tag, id, class, and attribute significant in a CSS selector?

Here is an example of HTML code to consider:

<input id="foo" class="bar" name="baz">

Do the following CSS selectors mean the same thing (or are they even valid):

CSS

input#foo.bar[name=baz] { }
input.bar#foo[name=baz] { }
input[name=baz].bar#foo { }
/* etc */

Is it possible to rearrange the order of tag, id, class, and attributes in the selector?

Edit: I understand specificity, I am interested in the sequence in which tag, id, class, and attributes should be specified.

Answer №1

All of these options are considered valid, meeting the syntax requirements outlined in the sequence of simple selectors. Their equivalence lies in the fact that their meaning and specificity are defined independently of the order in which they appear.

It is impossible to rearrange the element name (type selector) to the end due to syntactic restrictions. According to the specifications, a simple selector must always start with a type selector or a universal selector. No other type selector or universal selector can follow in the sequence. This rule ensures that if a type selector is present, it must be placed first to avoid confusion with preceding class selectors. The arrangement also prevents misinterpretations as certain characters like spaces have specific meanings in CSS selector syntax.

Answer №2

Check out the response provided by @Jukka as it appears that the original poster has altered the question slightly through edits. However, if you're interested in the specifics of the initial question before the edit, keep reading.


Neither of the selectors used seem to be logical and are actually considered too specific. Your selector already includes an id, making the addition of a class or attr=val unnecessary unless this same id is being used for another element in a different document.

If there arises a need to use additional specificity to override properties, then the following can be done:

input#foo.bar[name=baz] {
   /* More specificity overrides the selector below */
}

input[name=baz] {
   /* Styles here */
}

The question of whether the selectors mentioned above are equal - the answer is YES, they possess the same level of specificity which amounts to a score of 121.

Credits


Regarding their validity - they are deemed Completely Valid.


Does the order of tags, id, or class matter? - The answer is NO, the order of attributes does not affect the outcome.

However,

The order of your CSS declaration block within the stylesheet does make a difference; the last selector will take precedence over common properties since all three selectors have equal specificity.

Demo (All three will render green text, regardless of the order of their attributes. If you rearrange the CSS selectors block, the last one will override the shared properties of the prior two selectors - unless you include !important in one of the selector properties)


Is it possible to reposition the name attribute value to the end? - Absolutely, YES


Pros & Cons —

  • All the selectors are excessively specific
  • Impacts performance negatively
  • By using an attr=val selector, you are assuming that the value of the name attribute remains static. Any changes in these values would necessitate updating your selectors accordingly.

P.S : Make it a practice to quote attribute values.

Answer №3

Here are a few examples of legal selectors:

<input type-"text" id="foo" class="bar" name="baz">

input#foo.bar[name=baz] { border:1px solid blue; }
input.bar#foo[name=baz] { border:1px solid red; }
input[name=baz].bar#foo { border:1px solid green; }

http://jsfiddle.net/hGj5B/

If you remove the style blocks, you will see that each selector targets the textbox.

In terms of specificity, all three selectors in the examples have equal weight because they contain the same number of elements, classes, attribute selectors, and ids. Therefore, the order in which they appear in your stylesheet will determine which style prevails in case of conflicts.

It is not possible to reposition the element at the end as the other parts of the selector are used to define it.

Answer №4

Indeed, all of them are considered legal. However, during execution, the latter declaration will take precedence over the earlier ones, with a few exceptions.

To delve deeper into these exceptions, please refer to the following:

input[name=baz].bar#foo { border:1px solid green; }
input.bar#foo[name=baz] { border:1px solid red; }
input#foo.bar[name=baz] { border:1px solid blue; }
input { border:1px solid #000000; }

Explore an example on jsFiddle

For more detailed information, check out this question on Stack Overflow: The sequence of execution of CSS

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Error message: Information not displaying when window is minimized

When I minimize the window, the text is missing. The text overflows the sides of the window instead of wrapping downwards. Try running the code in a full window first, then adjust the width to see the issue. I've been unable to find a solution on m ...

Clickable boxes for selecting options (Ajax and JavaScript)

I have a new project that involves creating a checkbox and using ajax and javascript to change its state when clicked. The goal is for the checkbox state to be saved in a php program that generates a .txt file. The state should be 0 when not clicked and 1 ...

css malfunctioning user interface

I'm struggling to figure out how to design a CSS toolbar. My goal is to create a 22x22 button toolbar with 4 buttons. I have this PNG image: and the following code: <style> #nav {background: url(content/images/crtoolbar.png) no-repeat;height: ...

I'm having trouble getting these margin classes to work properly in Bootstrap. Can anyone help me figure out what

I'm new to using Bootstrap and struggling with adding margins between elements. I tried adding mb-12 to the navbar class and mt-12 to the container class, but it doesn't seem to be working as expected. Everything else in my code is functioning co ...

Transition Effect for Sub Menu Hover in Google Chrome

The top menu bar on my website has a second level dropdown that is functioning correctly in Firefox but not in Chrome. In Chrome, when I mouse out of the dropdown, the background color disappears before the links. This creates a slight timing gap between ...

React Native ellipsizeMode - Using two Text elements side by side

I am trying to achieve a layout similar to the following scenarios: Case 1: If the text is longer than the screen width +--------------------------------------+ | very long teeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee.. (1234)| +--------------------------------------+ Case 2: If ...

Error occurs when using Vue 3 Transition component with a child <slot> tag

I have developed a unique component that enables me to incorporate a smooth fading transition without the need to repeatedly use the <transition> element: <transition mode="out-in" enter-active-class="transition- ...

What could be causing the .slideToggle method to not function properly in jQuery?

Having some trouble with this code snippet: <div class="chat" style="display: none;"> <input type="text" class="chat-name" placeholder="Enter your name"> <div class="chat-messages"></div> <textarea class="chat-textar ...

The safari browser is not displaying the menu

I have recently been working on a new website and created a fresh menu for it. While the menu functions perfectly on browsers like Chrome and Firefox, I encountered an error when testing it on Safari. On Safari, the menu appears to be completely hidden. ...

What is the best way to customize the appearance of the material-ui select component using styled-components instead of material-ui classes in a React

I've been facing some challenges while trying to style my material-ui select component using styled-components instead of material- classes. The version I am working with is material-ui/core 4.12.3. When I use the old makeStyles component from materi ...

What is the best way to switch the direction of the arrows based on the sorting order?

Is there a way to dynamically change the direction of arrows based on sorting, similar to the example shown here? sortingPipe.ts: import { SprBitType } from '../spr-bit-type/sprBitType'; import { Pipe, PipeTransform } from '@angular/core& ...

Positioning a div in the center horizontally may result in content with a large explicit width being

I am in search of a solution to horizontally center content on a webpage, regardless of whether or not it has a defined width. After referencing a Stack Overflow question on centering a div block without the width, I found a great method that works well w ...

How to perfectly align the dropdown menu within Elementor and Wordpress

Seeking assistance to center the dropdown menu in relation to the parent menu. I am currently using Elementor on WordPress. So far, I have attempted the following CSS code without success: .header-menu { left: 50%; right: auto; text-align: ...

This message is designed to validate the form as it is dynamic and

Is there a way to dynamically determine which .input fields have not been entered yet? In the following code snippet, you can observe that if I input data out of sequence, the #message displays how many inputs have been filled and shows the message in sequ ...

How to dynamically change the color of a button in a list in Vue.js when it is clicked

I am working on a dynamic list of buttons that are populated using an array of objects: <div class="form-inline" v-for="(genre, index) in genreArray" :key="index" > ...

Can you propose a different approach to creating the "word stack" that overcomes the limitations of my current method?

I am attempting to convert a set of two radio buttons into a stack of two labels, one blue and one gray, to represent the selected radio button and the unselected one. Clicking on this stack will toggle which label is blue (and consequently which radio but ...

jQuery failing to trigger onClick event for a specific group of buttons

Javascript: <script> $(document).ready(function(){//Implementing AJAX functionality $(".acceptorbutton").on('click', function(){ var whichClicked = this.attr('name'); ...

Attempting to navigate the world of AJAX and PHP

My experience with AJAX is limited, but I am currently working on a project that requires a form to submit data without refreshing the page. The goal is to display the result in a modal window instead. To achieve this functionality, I understand that imple ...

`Locating an image alongside text for seamless integration`

Take a moment to view the image displayed below Feature 1 and feature 4 are two distinct divs that I have styled with the Bootstrap class .col-md-4 Here is the corresponding HTML code <div class="col-md-4"> <div class="feature-group-1"> ...

Display a unique text when a different option is selected in `<select>` elements

Is there a way to customize the displayed text in a <select> dropdown so that it differs from the actual content of the <option> tags? Due to limited width constraints, I need to find a solution that prevents any text from being cut off. For i ...