Is it more effective to implement react useState and conditional rendering for managing different screen sizes, or is it better to use

In my current project, I am using standard CSS3 and creating separate CSS files for each component. I am debating whether to incorporate an event listener with multiple return functions within my React component instead of having multiple media queries in the CSS file. Another option would be to use conditional classNames defined by useState to categorize screen sizes as small, medium, and large variables that could then be used in the CSS file for maintaining consistency in element sizing. This approach would prevent the need for creating numerous CSS files or media queries.

I am concerned about potential messiness in the future if certain screen sizes are updated while others are not using either method.

Is there a universal solution that I am overlooking? Or do you believe one of these approaches is superior to the other?

//My Current Approach

const Component = () => {
    const [width, setWidth] = useState();
    const [size, setSize] = useState('large');

    useEffect(() => {
        //add event handler...
        //setStates
    }, [states])

    if(size === 'small') return {
    <SmallComponent />
    } else if (size === 'large') return {
    <BigComponent />
    }
}

Answer №1

Implementing media queries for a responsive user interface is considered the recommended approach. By utilizing conditional rendering to adjust the UI based on screen size, it may lead to excessive renders, ultimately diminishing the overall quality of the React application. For enhanced performance and cleaner code structure, it is advisable to incorporate media queries as they offer a more seamless method for managing the UI across various screen sizes.

Answer №2

When it comes to designing, the approach you take depends on your specific needs.

  • If your goal is to automatically adjust components based on screen dimensions, then using media queries would be the preferred method. Trying to determine breakpoints through javascript may not be necessary in this case.
  • On the other hand, if you already know the size of the component you want to render at a given moment, you can simply pass that information as props. For example:
<Button size="small" />
<Button size="small" fullWidth />

For design inspiration, take a look at how material-ui approaches their designs. https://mui.com/material-ui/react-button

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Wrapping header text in Vuetify's v-data-table

Struggling with wrapping the header text on a v-data-table component. I've tried applying styles, but only tbody elements are affected. The header (thead element) remains unchanged. Any suggestions on how to get custom styling for the header? For ins ...

Tips for keeping notification icons in the upper right corner of the box?

I am facing an issue with absolute positioning where the notification icons I've positioned to the top-right corner of a box are moving away when the screen size changes. Desired appearance of the image Actual appearance when screen size is adjusted ...

What is the best way to insert a <dv> element following a <Typography> component in the provided code?

After learning React, I have attempted in various ways to get this code snippet to work. I referred to a question on Stackoverflow as well as the HTML div documentation The goal is to have the text and link displayed in a horizontal line, not vertically s ...

The art of pattern matching in Selenium using Python

Currently developing a Python program with Selenium to automate filling out an online form. After submitting the form, there are 3 potential redirections that could occur. I am in the process of creating a function to determine which page I am redirected ...

What steps can I take to resolve the issue of text/data overflow within material-ui?

Having an issue with data overflow in my MaterialTable from material-ui when viewed on mobile devices. It displays fine on desktop, but the table data spills over on smaller screens. How can I resolve this problem? <MaterialTable className={clas ...

The alignment of two elements is off in mobile display

Why aren't my two divs centered in mobile view? I am using Vuetify CSS flex helper justify-center to try and achieve it, but it doesn't seem to be working. Even when I use justify-sm-center, it still doesn't work. What am I missing? <v-co ...

Can separating state and dispatch into individual context providers help reduce unnecessary re-renders in your application?

In the example from the official next.js repository, I noticed that state and dispatch were placed into separate context providers. What was the reasoning behind this decision? Could this approach potentially help prevent unnecessary re-renders? export co ...

How can I maintain circle radius while resizing SVG to 100% width?

Our line graphs are drawn using SVG technology: https://i.stack.imgur.com/PLpPT.png When generating SVG, the width is set to 100%, but the exact value remains unknown. To ensure that the SVG fills the entire width without distortion, we use preserveAspec ...

Do I need to generate a sitemap for data retrieved from a database in NextJS?

I'm currently working with Prisma and NextJS to fetch data through dynamic routes. However, I am unsure about the functionality of SEO and sitemaps. Would it be necessary for me to generate a sitemap for each individual post such as /post/1? ...

What sets npm run build apart from next build, and npm run export different from next export?

In my upcoming project, I am aiming to create a static build for production. In order to do so, I referenced a tutorial that suggested using 'next build' and 'next export'. However, when I attempted the next build, an error occurred as ...

Discover the steps to modify the input field type with just a keypress in angularjs

I need help changing an input field type from text to password. Currently, I am able to change the input field type from text to password when clicking on it. However, I also want the type to change from text to password when tab is pressed. Any assistan ...

Having difficulty toggling a <div> element with jQuery

I am attempting to implement a button that toggles the visibility of a div containing replies to comments. My goal is to have the ability to hide and display the replies by clicking the button. The "show all replies" button should only appear if there are ...

Dynamically updating the ng-class name in AngularJS

Exploring the integration of animate.css with AngularJS. Attempting to assign a class to an element on ng-click, but facing difficulties in updating the element. Various strategies were attempted, including modifying scope values through functions, without ...

Exploring the functionality of closing Material UI Drawer on escape key in a React 16 app with RTL support

I am currently experimenting with the Material UI Drawer component. I expected it to close when pressing the Esc key or clicking outside of it, but unfortunately, it is not behaving as anticipated. I am utilizing the react testing library for my tests an ...

When attempting to send a fetch request in the most recent rendition of NextJS, it ends up with an error of 'failed fetch'

I am currently working on a nextjs (v.13.4.19) / strapi (v.4.12.5) application and facing issues when trying to make a request to the strapi endpoint using the fetch function. I have attempted several troubleshooting steps such as: changing localhost:1337 ...

"Unlocking the Potential of ReactJS: A Guide to Setting Focus on Components Once They Become

My code had a <div> with a child component named SocialPostwithCSS, and when onClick was triggered, it would hide the div, set the state to editing: true, and display a <textarea>. I used this.textarea.focus with a ref={(input)=>{this.textar ...

Combining Bootstrap Vue: utilizing class names alongside HTML tags

(Bootstrap-Vue 2.0, Vue.js 2.5) Is it possible to combine traditional CSS Bootstrap 4 classes with Bootstrap-Vue? For example, can I use the following code snippet: <section id="introduction"> <b-container class="h-100"> & ...

Limit the maximum column gap on the grid and stop it from expanding further

I'm currently facing an issue with some columns/rows on my website that are keeping content locked in the top left corner, reminiscent of early 00's web design. The site was originally designed for smaller screens like 1024x764, so when viewed on ...

What are the potential drawbacks of using this alternative method instead of `useCallback` in React to prevent unnecessary re-renders of children components?

While exploring some code, I stumbled upon an alternative method to prevent function recreation during renders compared to the official useCallback hook. This method seems to offer certain benefits over useCallback, but I am interested to know if there are ...

Leveraging vanilla-extract for customizing Material-UI's style engine

A Look into Styling Solutions Since embracing Material UI for a while now, our team has been exploring the latest styling options with the introduction of Material UI v5. With JSS being phased out by the MUI team, we found ourselves delving into a discuss ...