Does .NET MVC provide the necessary separation of HTML/CSS/JS for my project?

Currently, I am collaborating with my ASP.NET development team in an effort to improve the quality of our HTML output. We are facing challenges due to ASP.NET's tendency to insert JavaScript directly into the page, creating dependencies on JS for form controls to function properly. This has led to difficulties in achieving cleaner HTML without adding significant development time.

In the past, I have worked with MVC frameworks like Struts in Java, which allowed me to maintain full control over my HTML pages. This approach resulted in high-quality web pages that met my standards, even when integrating with Java programmers to complete the project.

I am now considering whether transitioning to .NET MVC would provide the level of separation I desire, or if it would require a substantial investment of time to evaluate. If .NET MVC falls short of meeting my needs, I would greatly appreciate any recommendations on coding practices or libraries within the .NET ecosystem that could help achieve this level of control.

javascripthtmlcssasp.net-mvc

Answer №1

By utilizing the ASP.NET MVC Framework, you will experience a greater level of separation that is more recognizable. With the absence of viewstate and other components in the MVC Framework, the concern of JavaScript cluttering your pages is eliminated. Any JavaScript calls present will be those that you intentionally include.

You have the ability to segregate HTML, CSS, and JS similar to how you would in an alternative framework.

Answer №2

Based on the selected view engine, it is possible.

To confirm, simply review the page source of stack-overflow. While not as elaborate as zen-garden, it is quite tidy.

Further explanation:

The view engine handles the page rendering. Whether using the standard engine or alternatives like nVelocity or Brail, the choice is yours, similar to monorail.

The output HTML relies on the selected view engine. Generally, most view engines perform better in this aspect compared to vanilla ASP.Net.

Answer №3

@Wrestlevania inquired:

Does anyone have any suggestions for best practices, libraries, or other resources for .NET coding that could be particularly beneficial?

When coding in ASP.Net, I prioritize maintaining a strong separation of concerns. By steering clear of asp controls and instead utilizing basic html elements whenever possible, I am able to prevent ASP.Net from injecting unnecessary CSS or JS into my page. For instance, I opt for using span instead of asp:literal and button in place of asp:button.

The only ASP control I incorporate is the repeater, primarily for generating tables. For any similar functionality, I either develop my own solution in javascript or leverage a framework like jQuery.

Answer №4

Utilizing Asp.Net MVC can streamline the process of separating html, css, and js by limiting the features that may impede this separation.

For instance, Html helpers in Asp.Net MVC tend to focus solely on generating html, giving users the flexibility to manage style information solely through class attributes.

Additionally, explore best practices commonly used with libraries such as jQuery as a model for maintaining scripted functionality within js files and keeping it separate from html. By assigning event handling behaviors to page elements during load based on element type, class, and id, the code remains clean and organized.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Execute a JavaScript function repeatedly, with a specified delay incorporated into it

I am currently working on a JavaScript function that cycles through background images within a div. The function works well, but it stops once all the images have been displayed. How can I make it start over again after going through all the images? $(do ...

javascriptjquery

What strategies can we implement to ensure consistency in visual styles and templates across our microservices?

Our team is currently working on multiple microservices simultaneously. While traditional microservice architecture discourages code sharing and reuse between services, we are considering the benefits of consistent styling across all services that have Web ...

cssstylesmicroservices

Transform the appearance of the navigation bar background upon scrolling in Bootstrap

I am trying to change the background color of my navigation bar from transparent to black when scrolling. I want it to function like this template: . Previous attempts using solutions from How to Change Navigation Bar Background with Scroll? and Changing n ...

javascripthtmljquerycssbootstrap-4

Gathering information from a website where the URL remains constant even after clicking on a specific button

Visit this website for bus tickets: I am working on scraping data related to bus trips from the mentioned site. However, the data I need to scrape depends on the user-selected date in my web application. Does anyone have suggestions on how I can develop ...

javascriptpythonjsonweb-scrapingbeautifulsoup

Error in Material UI: Cannot redeclare identifier 'Switch' - parsing issue

I am trying to incorporate the Material UI Switch component alongside the react-router-dom Switch in a single component. This is how I have included them in my react component: import { BrowserRouter as Router, Switch, Route } from "react-router-dom ...

javascriptreactjsmaterial-uireact-router-dom

Prevent selection based on function in Angular

I'm attempting to prevent certain options from being selected based on a specific method. For instance, let's say I have four options: A B C D In my method (let's use "x" as an example): if(name == A) { disable the selection for option A. ...

javascriptangularhtml-select

"Implementing a loading function on a particular div element within a loop using

Hey everyone! I'm new to this forum and have recently made the switch from jQuery to Vue.js - what a game-changer! However, I've hit a little snag. I need to set v-loading on multiple buttons in a loop and have it start showing when clicked. Her ...

javascriptvue.jsvuejs2vue-component

Each time forEach is called, it increments the previous result by 1

My service returns a response containing the following data: {"id":157336,"results":[ {"id":"53db3c790e0a26189a000d09","iso_639_1":"en","key":"ePbKGoIGAXY","name":"Trailer 3","site":"YouTube","size":1080,"type":"Trailer"}, {"id":"550df44b925141355 ...

javascriptangularjs

Personalizing HTML input fields

I am looking to create a contact form that will display an image depending on whether the input entered is correct or incorrect. My goal is to achieve this using only HTML and CSS, without needing any JavaScript. While there are similar posts on this topic ...

htmlcss

The parameter in a JavaScript for loop

I'm struggling with my Javascript skills. Here is the code snippet I am currently working with: var information = [ {"Column":"","keyw":"","Column_3":"day of march 2011 to someother numeric" ...

javascriptjson

Admin-on-rest sidebar navigation menu

Hello everyone! I am new to ReactJS and admin-on-rest. I am currently studying from this documentation and I am interested in creating a navigation submenu similar to the one shown here. I have tried searching on Google but haven't found what I need. ...

javascriptreactjsmaterial-designmaterial-ui

Retrieving CSS file using admin-ajax.php in WordPress

The website has been tested on GTmetrix and you can view the report here I am puzzled as to why admin-ajax.php is causing a delay of over 3 seconds in loading time on this particular page that I am attempting to optimize. It seems to be related to a CSS ...

phpcssajaxwordpressadmin-ajax

Expanding functionality: Steps to integrating a new endpoint into your AWS Amplify Express Server

I have created a REST express server using Amplify. Attempted to include two additional endpoints: // incorporating serverless express app.post('/myendpoint', function(req, res) { console.log('body: ', req.body) res.json(req.body) ...

javascriptamazon-web-servicesrestexpressaws-amplify

Establishing the NumbroJS cultural settings

I have been attempting to modify numbro's culture. I initially tried the straightforward method, but encountered an error: Unknown culture : ' + code numbro.culture('fr-FR'); My attempt looked like this: const br = require('numb ...

javascriptnode.js

Experiencing the Pause: A Fresh Take on

I'm currently using this slideshow for a project, and I need to understand if it's possible to resume its interval. The current issue is that when you hover over the slideshow, the progress bar stops. But once you remove the mouse, it continues f ...

javascriptjqueryhtmlcssslideshow

How to efficiently deliver a document to a user using the MEAN stack

The express controller code snippet I'm working with involves creating a CSV file and sending it back to the user: // Correct file path and write data var currentDate = new Date(); var storagePath = path.join(__dirname,'../../public/reports/&apo ...

javascriptangularjsnode.jsmeanjs

Use jQuery to trigger a click event when an element is in focus, unless it was clicked to

I am currently developing a website using the MDL framework. One issue I encountered is that there is no default select form element provided. After some research, I found a solution by utilizing a menu component that displays when the input is clicked. Th ...

javascriptjqueryhtmlmaterial-design-lite

Change the order of the div to be placed before the previous element

In this scenario, the third div is positioned to the right of the second div rather than the first div. There is space available to the right of the first div, but it is constrained from appearing above the second div. How can I adjust the placement of th ...

htmlcss

Discovering the Authentic Page upon Completion of Load using PhantomJS

I am facing an issue while automatically downloading a theme on Wordpress using PhantomJS. The problem arises because the page is not fully evaluated even after it appears to be done loading. When trying to interact with elements on the page, such as clic ...

javascriptwordpressphantomjs

Stop jQuery Tab from Initiating Transition Effect on Current Tab

Currently, I am utilizing jQuery tabs that have a slide effect whenever you click on them. My query is: How can one prevent the slide effect from occurring on the active tab if it is clicked again? Below is the snippet of my jQUery code: $(document).read ...

javascriptjqueryhtml