Assessing the performance of YUi and BackBone

As I embark on a new project, one of the crucial decisions to make is regarding the architecture.

Currently, I am contemplating the selection of front-end components.

I plan to utilize HTML5, CSS3, and Javascript for this purpose.

When it comes to choosing between YUI or Backbone for the Javascript framework, I find myself in a dilemma. I am uncertain about how best to evaluate which option suits my requirements as I aim to develop both a Browser web app and a Mobile app.

Would you recommend any other frameworks for achieving this goal? Perhaps there are books, URLs, or resources that can guide me on how to effectively organize the front-end structure?

Answer №1

While it may be a bit belated to add my thoughts, I feel compelled to share my perspective on the various frameworks I have explored:

Among them are Angular, Knockout, Backbone, and YUI. After reading up on Ember as well.

In my experience, both Angular and Knockout take a similar initial approach by focusing on front-end integration. Personally, I find this aspect less appealing as it leaves ample room for error in designing a robust architecture. The burden of creating an effective MVC application falls solely on the developer with these tools.

YUI bears a striking resemblance to Backbone, perhaps due to being inspired by it. My extensive examination of Backbone has left me impressed with its principles and standards. It encourages the development of a sturdy framework if adhered to diligently.

Interestingly, I came across a comment from someone who transitioned from Backbone to YUI citing the latter as more streamlined and superior overall. While I cannot confirm this claim yet, it warrants further investigation from my end.

Many individuals, myself included, argue that Ember, Knockback, and Angular have a somewhat heavy-handed approach. They prioritize explaining HTML interfacing from the outset, which may either pose challenges or simplify tasks depending on one's specific project requirements.

This is simply my viewpoint based on personal observations and experiences!

Answer №2

Backbone is a versatile tool for building web applications that work well on both desktop and mobile devices. Its simplicity and compact size make it stand out, as you can easily navigate through its complete annotated source code. Backbone aids in organizing your code in a way that is easy to maintain, which is its main advantage.

On the flip side, backbone can be intimidating for beginners due to the complexity of setting up collections, models, and views. Additionally, it doesn't assist much with rendering views, which can be seen as both a positive and a negative. While it lacks the convenience of widget-based frameworks, it also gives you more freedom without unnecessary constraints, making it ideal for mobile app development.

If you're new to backbone, I suggest exploring the todo-example provided on their website ( ) to grasp the basics of how the framework operates.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

What is the best way to implement colorful opening hours in code?

I found this code on a different platform and decided to tweak it to display only Monday - Friday, Saturday, and Sunday. However, I'm stuck trying to update the Javascript code to match my modifications. Any help would be appreciated! You can view th ...

Ways to set the minimum width of a div depending on its contents

As I work on my website, I encountered an issue with a div containing a table. The div expands to full width, but when I resize the screen, it shrinks causing the content to overlap. I am looking for a solution where the minimum width of the div adjusts b ...

Updating the background of the <html> tag using jQuery

Is there a way to modify this CSS using jQuery? html { background: yellow; } Attempting the following code does not yield the desired results: $('html').css('background','red'); ...

swapping out an external CSS file in React for a new CSS file

My React app is quite large and includes four main CSS files (darkLTR, lightLTR, darkRTL, lightRTL), which may not be the most efficient setup. The templates were provided by my boss, and I was instructed to use them instead of Material UI, which I initial ...

Is there a way to consistently maintain a specific column size in Bootstrap?

I'm currently working on a website and running into an issue that I can't seem to resolve. The problem lies in the layout of multiple cards with information; they are arranged in columns and when there are more than 4 columns, they switch to a ne ...

What is the process for customizing the image size of a WordPress RSS feed in pixels?

Is there a way to customize image sizes beyond the 'thumbnail', 'medium', and 'large' options? I tried setting width and height in the <img> tag within an RSS file, but it didn't work. Could it be a nested quotation ...

Consistent Row Heights for Dynamic Width Elements

I've relied on Chris Coyier's Equal Height Blocks in Rows jQuery script for various projects, and it has consistently delivered great results. However, this time I am facing a new challenge as I work on a responsive website with a fluid width ma ...

What could be causing my canvas to not display my sprite?

Currently, I am in the process of learning JavaScript and experimenting with creating games to make the learning experience more enjoyable. However, I am facing an issue while using EaselJS and CreateJS to develop these games as a beginner. I need some as ...

Tips for troubleshooting objects within an Angular template in an HTML file

When I'm creating a template, I embed some Angular code within my HTML elements: <button id="btnMainMenu" class="button button-icon fa fa-chevron-left header-icon" ng-if="(!CoursesVm.showcheckboxes || (CoursesVm.tabSelected == 'curren ...

Select from a variety of backgrounds using the dropdown menu on the site

I seem to be struggling with javascript and php, but I know that in order to make this function properly, I need to utilize both languages. My goal is to set up a "select box" featuring 4 different images. There will be a default image displayed, but user ...

Is there a way to dynamically import several CSS files in React Native depending on the data stored in this.state?

How can I dynamically import multiple CSS files in a React Native project based on language? import React, { Component } from "react"; if(this.state.language === "he"){ import styles from "./he"; }else{ import styles from "./en"; } I attempted the ab ...

The click() function in jQuery executing only once inside a "for" loop

This is an example of my HTML code: <!DOCTYPE html> <head> <title>Chemist</title> <link href="stylesheet.css" rel="stylesheet"> </head> <body> <h2 id="money"></h2> <table border="1px ...

display the text content of the chosen option on various div elements

I created a subscription form that includes a category dropdown select field. The selected option's text value needs to appear 4 times within the form. It's all part of a single form. <select name="catid" onchange="copy()" id="catid" class="i ...

Refreshing HTML tables with AJAX in Django

After going through all the posts here, I found that some are outdated and others don't quite match my issue. Apologies for bringing it up again. I have a basic HTML table with data in it. My goal is to update this data without refreshing the entire ...

Verifying the number of div elements within an if condition

I've been attempting to determine the number of div elements in my DOM. However, when I try to assign this count to a variable, it displays as undefined in the console. Strangely, when I utilize an alert, it correctly shows the value as "8". My goal ...

Tips for ensuring that all children within a flex-container have equal heights

I seem to be facing an issue with this problem. My goal is to ensure that all the child divs within a flex container have the same height as the tallest child div, which in this case is 100px. Additionally, I want them to be aligned at the center. I&apos ...

Refresh the webpage source code for an AJAX request

When using AJAX calls on a page, I have noticed that the page source remains unchanged. This can be problematic if a user performs forward/backward operations in their browser, as the browser will display the original HTML code instead of the updated conte ...

Place an IconButton component next to each Material UI TableRow

I am trying to include an icon next to the material UI table row component. Similar to the hint icon shown in the screenshot below Here is my attempt so far, but it's not functioning as expected: Check out the code on CodeSandbox https://i.stack.i ...

Angular Digest Loop for Dynamic Photo Grid Styling

I have a special filter that alters the objects being filtered. However, when I apply ng-style="item.gridSize", it triggers my custom grid algorithm. This algorithm was adapted for my requirements from a source found at this link. angular.module("custom.m ...

What are the best scenarios for implementing jQuery-ui plugin as opposed to Backbone View?

I am feeling uncertain about the concept of "componentization" in web UI development. When I need a component, should I develop my own jQuery-UI plugin or opt for creating a MarionetteComponent if I am using Backbone.Marionette? Both options provide reusa ...