The MinWidth property in ColumnDefinition is not functioning as expected

Currently, I am encountering an unusual issue while using a Grid in WPF (XAML) and setting the MinWidth property in a ColumnDefinition. When I have 9 ColumnDefinitions with 'Width="*"' specified for each one, and then apply the MinWidth property to one of the middle columns, it affects the sizes of the other columns in an unexpected way.

To better illustrate this problem, take a look at the following XAML code snippet:

  <Grid Width="500">  
    <Grid.ColumnDefinitions>
        <ColumnDefinition Width="*"/>
        <ColumnDefinition Width="*"/>
        <ColumnDefinition Width="*"/>
        <ColumnDefinition Width="*" MinWidth="250"/>
        <ColumnDefinition Width="*"/>
        <ColumnDefinition Width="*"/>
        <ColumnDefinition Width="*"/>
        <ColumnDefinition Width="*"/>
        <ColumnDefinition Width="*"/>
    </Grid.ColumnDefinitions>
    <Border Grid.Column="0" Background="Green"/>
    <Border Grid.Column="1" Background="Blue"/>
    <Border Grid.Column="2" Background="Red"/>
    <Border Grid.Column="3" Background="Yellow"/>
    <Border Grid.Column="4" Background="Purple"/>
    <Border Grid.Column="5" Background="Orange"/>
    <Border Grid.Column="6" Background="Azure"/>
    <Border Grid.Column="7" Background="LightBlue"/>
    <Border Grid.Column="9" Background="LightGreen"/>
  </Grid>

If you execute this XAML code, you'll notice that the first 3 columns have different widths compared to the last 5 columns, whereas the expectation was for all columns to have equal width.

Is there a known issue causing this behavior? Are there any proper solutions to handle this correctly?

Your help is greatly appreciated.

Answer â„–1

It appears that the columns to the left of the yellow one are wider than those to the right, despite being intended to have equal proportions.

This issue seems like a bug, especially since the following workaround solves it:

<Grid.ColumnDefinitions>
    <ColumnDefinition Width="*"/>
    <ColumnDefinition Width="*"/>
    <ColumnDefinition Width="*"/>
    <ColumnDefinition Width="1.0000001*" MinWidth="250"/>
    <ColumnDefinition Width="*"/>
    <ColumnDefinition Width="*"/>
    <ColumnDefinition Width="*"/>
    <ColumnDefinition Width="*"/>
    <ColumnDefinition Width="*"/>
</Grid.ColumnDefinitions>

This problem might be linked to how the columns are categorized by width...

Answer â„–2

It seems that this is just how it operates. You have set a limit of 500 points for the grid and instructed it to ensure each column has the same width, but also must be at least 250 points wide. Now WPF is questioning your request: How can I give each of the 9 columns a minimum of 250 points within the constraint of 500 points? The compromise is made to prioritize the minimum width, resulting in sacrifices from the other columns.

So, what is the correct approach for achieving this? What exactly are you aiming for?

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Difficulty arises when collapsed text in Bootstrap clashes with the footer design

Hey there! I'm working on this website using Bootstrap, and I've encountered a problem. When you click the "See Wikipedia" button, the content expands and overlaps the footer in a strange way without changing the page height. I've tried adju ...

Troubleshooting a problem with the navigation links on a single-page website with a

My website alampk.com features a single page layout with a fixed navbar at the top. However, when I click on links like exp, portfolio, etc., the section moves to the top but a portion of 50px gets covered by the navbar. I have tried various CSS and jQuery ...

Applying CSS onmousemove does not function properly in conjunction with Bootstrap framework

Currently, I have a code snippet that enables an absolutely positioned box to follow the movement of the mouse cursor: $(document).mousemove( function(e) { $(".wordbox").css({ top: "calc(" + e.pageY + "px - 0.8em)", left: e.pageX }) ...

Creating a div overlay triggered by the addition of a child tag

Using the Paypal zoid feature, I have a button that opens an iframe in the parent div when clicked. However, the iframe causes the other contents of the website to shift around, making it look messy. I'm wondering if there is a way to make the parent ...

Click event to reset the variable

The code snippet in Javascript below is designed to execute the function doSomethingWithSelectedText, which verifies if any text is currently selected by utilizing the function getSelectedObj. The getSelectedObj function returns an object that contains in ...

Optimizing mobile page layouts with CSS

I'm putting in a lot of effort to ensure that my simple form page is optimized for mobile devices. Although the form is visible, I find myself having to zoom in quite a bit in order to read it. Here's an example: ...

width restriction to only accommodate on two lines

Whether my text is short or long, I always want to ensure that it remains within two lines by defining the width of my div. Short Text +-------------------------+ | Short text goes here | | Short text goes here | +---------------------- ...

"Escape the confines of traditional div sections with the dynamic features of

In the beginning, I have arranged two rows of three divs on my webpage, which is how I intend to use them later. However, when testing the 'mobile view', the divs in the section overflow and move into the next part below the section. This causes ...

Arranging divs with HTML and CSS

I am currently facing issues with the positioning of 3 scripts in my HTML file. The vertical gauge is overlapping the second circular gauge, despite trying different positioning options to no avail. How can I adjust the layout so that the vertical gauge a ...

Adding text and buttons to the initial image in the slider: a step-by-step guide

I'm facing an issue with my html image slider as I try to add buttons and text to the first image but it keeps getting overridden. <div id="captioned-gallery"> <figure class="slider"> <figure> & ...

Troubles with NextJS and TailwindCSS Styling

I encountered a strange issue when I used the component separately. Here's how the code looked like: <> <Head> <title>Staycation | Home</title> <meta name="viewport" content="initial- ...

What is the best way to ensure that my <h1> header stays above my <h2> header at all times?

As a novice in web design, I recently took on the challenge of creating my own website. I am a graphic designer and came up with a mock-up of how I envision the site to look. While I managed to complete most parts of it, there's one specific area wher ...

How to create nested nav menus that are optimized for touch-screen devices?

When it comes to creating responsive websites, one challenge I frequently encounter is designing a multi-level nav menu that functions effectively for touch devices. Many plugins and methods exist, but most fall short because they do not allow a second-l ...

What is the process for extracting content from CSS comments or annotations in a stylesheet?

Here's an interesting concept: allowing users to define a set of CSS rules with annotations. For example: /* @name Page style */ body { font: 16px/1.5 Arial; /* @editable */ background-color: #fff; /* @editable */ } /* @name Section header */ ...

What is the best way to use toggleClass on a specific element that has been extended

I have been experimenting with this code snippet for a while. The idea is that when I hover my mouse over the black box, a red box should appear. However, it doesn't seem to be working as expected. Could someone please review this script and let me k ...

Style selector for dynamic drop-down menus

import React, { Component } from "react"; export default class FontChanger extends Component{ constructor(props){ super(props); this.state ={ selectedFont: "", currentFont: "", }; this.handleFon ...

Is it possible for a div element to maintain a fixed position even as its size changes

Looking to adjust the size of a ruler? In horizontal mode, the ruler expands and contracts as you resize it. However, in vertical mode, the ruler shifts left as you shrink it and right as you expand it. You can resize the ruler by dragging the small r ...

Troubleshooting regex validation issues in a JSFiddle form

Link to JSFiddle I encountered an issue with JSFiddle and I am having trouble figuring out the root cause. My aim is to validate an input using a regex pattern for a person's name. $("document").ready(function() { function validateForm() { var ...

Displaying information collected from a submission form

I am in the process of designing a cheerful birthday card and I need to transfer data from a form to the birthday card page. How can I take information from the first div (which contains the form) and display that data in the second div? <!DOCTYPE ...

Getting 100% height on floated neighboring divs: Tips and tricks

​<div id='container'> <div class='left'></div> <div class='right'></div> <div class='clear'></div> </div>​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​â ...