Is it necessary to define all presentational images in CSS?

Lately, I've been diving into the world of (X)HTML & CSS and have come to understand that HTML is meant for structure while CSS is used for presentation.

It makes me wonder if a significant portion of images on websites are more about enhancing presentation rather than structural necessity. In light of this, it seems logical to place these images in the CSS file and simply reference them in the HTML using div or span elements - think logos, header images, and backgrounds.

Despite this principle, many examples in my learning materials still include images directly within the HTML rather than specifying them strictly in the CSS. (I'm referring specifically to images that don't carry essential structural information but serve a presentational role, unlike photos on a photo-sharing site).

So, should all non-essential images be moved to CSS? Or are there technical or logical reasons behind keeping them integrated into the HTML?

Appreciate any insights, Grant

htmlcss

Answer №1

When dealing with images in various contexts, make sure to use the appropriate method. For images that are considered "content," such as those in a newspaper article, utilize the img tag. However, if the image is part of your UI, theme, or design elements, then CSS is the way to go.

Recommended reading materials:

  • Designing with Web Standards by Zeldman
  • Bullet Proof Web Design by Dan Cederholm
  • CSS Mastery by Andy Clark, Andy Budd, Cameron Moll

Answer №2

Utilizing CSS to place images can be advantageous for catering to various browsers on a single website by simply adjusting the CSS. For instance, identifying a mobile or pocket browser could lead to presenting them with identical HTML content but using a CSS version that omits images.

Answer №3

Whenever possible, I like to incorporate them into CSS. One reason being that they seem to fit there as you pointed out, and another is the potential for utilizing sprites. This can greatly decrease the loading time of your website.

Answer №4

According to the HTML 4.01/XHTML 1.0 DTD, it is mandatory to include the src property in an img tag. This ensures proper functionality of the image within the HTML structure.

In certain cases, the src property can be specified in CSS for customization purposes. However, since most images remain static and do not change frequently, placing the src property in CSS is often deemed unnecessary.

Answer №5

It really comes down to the specific requirements of your project. For instance, if you're looking to add some interactive effects when the mouse hovers over an image, it's best to include the image in the HTML. By doing so, you have more control over its positioning compared to using CSS alone. Additionally, embedded images in HTML are more likely to be recognized by search engines, which could be important for showcasing your company's logo.

From an accessibility standpoint, embedding images in HTML allows you to add alt text and title information. This means that when users hover over your company's logo, they can see additional information like the company motto if you include the appropriate attributes in the img tag. This level of customization is not easily achievable with CSS alone.

Traditionally, people have been accustomed to placing images directly within the HTML rather than relying solely on CSS. Changing this behavior can be challenging and may disrupt user experience.

In conclusion, if your project requires a high degree of flexibility and customization, it's recommended to embed images in the HTML. However, if CSS meets your needs for decorative UI images, then utilizing CSS might be a better option.

Answer №6

At times, when you load UI images using CSS, it can prevent users from easily saving those images to their devices while bookmarking a page.

There are alternative methods for saving the images, but it's worth noting this point.

Browsers typically prioritize CSS over HTML, so loading images via CSS may lead to slightly faster loading times compared to loading them through HTML.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

What is the counterpart of `width: max(100%, fit-content)`?

In order for my div to adjust its size based on the content if the parent div is smaller than the content, and match the size of the parent otherwise, I have been trying to achieve the first scenario by using width: fit-content, and the second scenar ...

css

What are the steps to format text into 2 columns with a personalized design?

As I develop a website using HTML, CSS, and jQuery, I encountered a layout challenge. The text on the page is designed in a 2-column style, with an image positioned before it. Currently, the structure looks like this: <div> <div style=" ...

jqueryhtmlcss

Using Vue to bind a class attribute with multiple Tailwind classes

I am attempting to associate an attribute and multiple tailwind classes with an HTML element. This is specifically for a tab menu where the goal is to dynamically display the title of the "active" tab and apply additional tailwind classes to modify the app ...

javascriptcssvue.jstailwind-css

The canvas map has an unseen boundary on the right, causing all other div sections to be

When I set the width of my google map canvas to 80%, the map itself fills that percentage but leaves a wide space to the right of the canvas, taking up the remaining 20% of the screen. This creates an issue because my div cannot be placed in that space. ...

htmlcsscanvasmaps

Ways to manipulate the placement of angular material 2 sidenav content to the bottom

I have been experimenting with various methods in CSS to override the existing side nav component in Angular Material 2. mat-sidenav-container { background: white; bottom: 0px !important; /* <---- no success */ } mat-sidenav { width: 300px; ...

cssangularangular-material2

How can you save the output of console.log in JavaScript to a variable and then use that variable in HTML?

Here is the code snippet I've been working on. The first part consists of JavaScript code, and the second part includes HTML. $('#table').on('check.bs.table', function (e, row) { checkedRows.push({First: row.fname, Second: row ...

javascriptjqueryhtmltwitter-bootstrap

The FaceBook modal is failing to appear

Attempting to implement FaceBook Login through a modal. Upon clicking the button below, the FaceBook Login Modal should appear. <li> <a href="#sign-in-dialog" class="login sign-btn" title="Sign In">Sign In</a> </li> The HTML co ...

htmlbootstrap-4modal-dialog

Challenges with border-color and CSS input:focus

The dilemma Currently, I am immersed in a project focusing on constructing a front end using bootstrap4. In order to align with the company's main color scheme, I decided to alter the highlighting color of inputs. To achieve this, I made the followi ...

htmlcssinputbootstrap-4frontend

Scraping the web using Python for HTML data retrieval

I'm working on a Python program to retrieve the card sub-brand and brand based on a card BIN number. The URL for this information is: . The code snippet below fetches the card type from the page. page = requests.get('https://www.cardbinist.com/s ...

pythonhtmlweb-scraping

Insert title into PDF document

I am currently working on a react application that generates PDF documents easily. The libraries I have utilized are: jspdf html2canvas Below is the code snippet that demonstrates my approach: index.js: <div className="App"> < ...

javascripthtmlreactjspdfjspdf

Page showing without banner

As I scroll down through my website, I want a specific banner to appear when I reach the contact page. The banner will show a goodbye message and give users the option to close it or keep it open. For example: (function() { requestAnimationFrame(fu ...

javascripthtmlcssweb-deployment

What is the best way to reach the assets/public directory from a routed page in Meteor?

I am currently developing a multipage application using Meteor and am facing an issue accessing public assets from a routed page. For instance, when I go to the route http://localhost:3000/editor, I would like to be able to utilize an image from public/im ...

htmlmeteoriron-router

Capture audio using a web browser

Currently working on a project to create a platform for recording sounds. I'm aiming to incorporate a meter that measures the volume of the sound. Despite extensive research, I haven't been able to discover an HTML5 solution compatible with all b ...

jqueryhtml

What is the best way to conceal the li elements that exceed a single line?

I have a unordered list containing product information as list items. My goal is to hide the list items that do not fit on a single line based on the screen size. Therefore, the number of products displayed should adjust depending on how many can fit on a ...

jqueryhtmlcss

What is the best way to retrieve the URL of a website using scrapy?

Currently, I am faced with the challenge of scraping the Amazon website using Scrapy. While I have successfully extracted items like product titles and prices, I am struggling to figure out how to extract the URL of a product (as shown in the image at the ...

pythoncssweb-scrapingurlscrapy

In Bootstrap 4.4.1, there is a known issue where HTML may not be rendered properly after a certain section

There seems to be an issue with the placement of my buttons section in the markup. It does not appear after the DIV containing the select tag, but it does when placed before it. I have tried moving the buttons section around to troubleshoot, and it does s ...

htmlcssbootstrap-4

Discover the power of EJS embedded within HTML attributes!

There are two cases in which I am attempting to use an EJS tag within an HTML attribute. SITUATION 1: <input style="background-image: url(<%= img.URL %>)" /> SITUATION 2: <input onchange="handleCheckboxChange(<%= i ...

javascripthtmlnode.jsejs

Creating a user-friendly navigation menu: A step-by-step guide

I need help creating a navigation menu for my website that isn't functioning properly. Here is the code I am currently using: body{ margin: 0px; padding: 0px; } nav > ul{ margin: 0px; padding: 0px; } nav > ul > li{ fl ...

htmlcss

Use jQuery to create a price filter that dynamically sets slide values based on the filter object

I'm currently utilizing the jQuery slide filter to sort products based on price. The filtering value is set within the script, but I am interested in dynamically setting it based on the highest/lowest number found on my page using a data attribute. D ...

javascriptjqueryhtml

ui-grid row size set to automatically adjust using rowHeight : 'auto'

Has anyone else experienced this strange behavior with ui-grid? When I set the rowHeight to auto, each cell in the same row ends up with different heights. One of the cells contains multiline data, which seems to be causing issues for ui-grid. I've ev ...

javascriptcssangularjsng-gridangular-ui-grid