Is it better to specify the image size in the height/width attributes of the img tag or in CSS settings?

What is the recommended coding practice for defining an image's size?

<img src="images/academia_vs_business.png" width="740" height="382" alt="" />

Should the size be defined in the CSS style with width/height attributes instead?

<img src="images/academia_vs_business.png" style="width:740px; height:382px;" alt="" />

Or is it better to use both methods together?

<img src="images/academia_vs_business.png" width="740" height="382" style="width:740px; height:382px" alt="" />

Answer №1

Let's break away from the traditional thinking and consider that separating content from layout doesn't always mean using CSS is the answer when it comes to image height and width.

Each image inherently holds its own unique height and width values, which can be seen as part of the content rather than just layout. These dimensions should be included in the HTML code as element attributes.

This concept is similar to providing "alt" text for images, where the information serves a purpose beyond just aesthetics. In scenarios where certain user agents may not interpret CSS, having this data readily available can enhance the user experience.

While the specification allows for the use of "width" and "height" attributes to override the original dimensions of an image, I advocate for relying on CSS for such modifications instead.

In essence, the decision to include height and width attributes in the HTML versus using CSS for styling will depend on the desired outcome. Ideally, the primary dimensions should be specified in the HTML structure, while CSS can be utilized for additional design elements.

Answer №2

One of the reasons why it is important to define height and width in tags is for browsers to size the actual <img> elements on the page before CSS and image resources are loaded. Without explicitly supplying height and width, the <img> element will initially render at 0x0 until the browser can determine its size based on the file. This can result in a visual reflow of the page once the image loads, especially if there are multiple images on the page. By setting the height and width via attributes, a physical space is allocated for the image in the correct dimensions, allowing content to load asynchronously without disrupting the user experience.

For mobile-responsive design, it is common practice to specify a width (or max-width) only and set the height as auto. This allows for easier adjustment of image width through media queries for different screen widths, while letting the browser handle the image height and aspect ratio. Although some reflow may occur, this approach enables support for a wide range of screen sizes, often outweighing any negatives.

In instances where the image size is unknown ahead of time (such as dynamically loaded image sources or changing images during page execution), using CSS alone may be more appropriate.

Ultimately, weighing the trade-offs and understanding which strategy best aligns with your goals is crucial in determining the most effective approach.

Answer №3

Although using inline styles is acceptable, you may find it more beneficial to incorporate an external CSS file into your webpage. By doing so, you can establish a class for images (such as 'Thumbnail', 'Photo', 'Large', etc) and assign them a consistent size. This will come in handy when you have images that need to be placed the same way on various pages.

For example:

Include this in your header:
<link type="text/css" rel="stylesheet" href="css/style.css" />

Add this to your HTML:
<img class="thumbnail" src="images/academia_vs_business.png" alt="" />

In css/style.css:
img.thumbnail {
   width: 75px;
   height: 75px;
}

If you prefer to use inline styles, it's recommended to specify the width and height using the style attribute for better readability.

Answer №4

Definitely not both options combined. In my opinion, the choice between CSS and HTML for styling images comes down to personal preference. If I have many images of the same size, I would opt for CSS to streamline the code.

.my_images img {width: 20px; height:20px}

In the long run, CSS may prove to be more advantageous due to the deprecation of HTML attributes and the increasing popularity of vector image formats like SVG. With this shift, it becomes feasible to scale images using units other than pixels, such as % or em.

Answer №5

<img id="myUniqueImageId" src"uniqueImage" width="120" height="120" />

Including width and height attributes in the image tag is a beneficial habit. By doing this, space is reserved for the image when the page loads, preventing any layout disruptions even if the image loading process takes longer than expected.

Answer №6

Choice 1. Simple and straightforward. What you see is what you get, making calculations easy.

Choice 2. It's too cluttered to do inline unless you want a site that can expand. If you used the width:86em, modern browsers handle this well for my needs. Personally, I would only consider using something like this if I were creating a thumbnail catalog.

/*css*/
ul.myThumbs{}
ul.myThumbs li {float:left; width:50px;}
ul.myThumbs li img{width:50px; height:50px;border:0;}

<!--html-->
<ul><li>
<img src="~/img/products/thumbs/productid.jpg" alt="" />
</li></ul>

Choice 3. Too complicated to keep up with.

Answer №7

Utilizing the contentEditable feature for rich text editing on my app has been quite the journey. I recently discovered a peculiar issue when inserting and resizing images within the editor.

<img style="width:55px;height:55px" width="100" height="100" src="pic.gif" border=0/>

Surprisingly, certain inserted images had an unexpected "rogue" style attribute and parameter attached to them. However, this only seemed to affect the rendering in IE7, where the image was displayed at the intended 55px x 55px size.

Upon exporting the content to a MS Word document, I noticed that all resized images reverted back to their original dimensions. It turns out that MS Word disregards the inline styles and reverts to the default image size specified in the HTML attributes.

After some investigation, I developed a JavaScript function to extract the style width and height values and transfer them to the img tag directly before saving the content to the database. This resolved the sizing discrepancies encountered during export.

Cheers!

Oh, one more thing... My recommendation is to keep both attributes directly under the img tag rather than using the style attribute.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

@page Css not displaying properly on the Mozilla Firefox browser

In order to fulfill my requirement, I need to ensure that there is a consistent 10cm margin on all pages when printing. Printing on my web page involves utilizing the window.print() function. However, due to the dynamic nature of the content, the number o ...

Tips for implementing draggable elements using JavaScript and React hooks, creating a more interactive user experience

I'm working on a project where I need to incorporate draggable divs, each corresponding to an image in an array of images, into a container. The current implementation seems to function properly, but there's an issue - the dragging action only w ...

Buttons and links with intricate geometries

I am currently developing a web application using Java/JSF and I am interested in finding out about technologies that would allow me to define intricate shapes as clickable buttons or links. Right now, my only option is to split an image into smaller trans ...

Tips for customizing the appearance of an HTML dropdown menu

Here is the code snippet: <select name="xyz" id="abc"> <option value="x">10/Page</option> <option value="y">20/Page</option> <option value="z">30/Pa ...

Leveraging an AngularJS variable within an iframe

Is it possible to use a variable inside an iframe src or ng-src attribute? I've tried different variables but none seem to be recognized. For example: <iframe ng-src="http://www.example.com/?name={{test}}"> </iframe> The variable test ju ...

Is it possible to have the navigation bar (bootstrap) appear on top of my slider as the default setting, without taking up additional space?

I'm encountering a rather simple issue that's giving me some trouble. I'm currently working on a website design using Bootstrap, and initially, there were no image sliders included by default. After integrating an image slider, I noticed th ...

The width of my root container does not display at a full 100% in mobile dimensions

After creating a simple React.js project, I set up the folder structure using `npx create-react-app`. Additionally, I added some styling with `* { margin: 0; padding: 0; box-sizing: border-box }`, and specified background colors for the body and #root elem ...

Preventing blank text entries in a task management application

Is there a way to determine if the text input provided by the user is empty or contains some text? I'm in the process of developing a TO-DO app and I'd like it so that if a user fails to enter anything into the text area and clicks on "add", the ...

Visual Studio 2017 experiencing compatibility issues with Bootstrap

I've been working on creating a carousel using bootstrap within Visual Studio 2017. I utilized the NuGet package manager to install jQuery and Bootstrap, and to test its functionality, I generated a bootstrap snippet for the carousel. Take a look at ...

Changing the format of PHP SQL results from vertical to horizontal

Is there a way to convert the vertical table generated by the following code into a horizontal one with stylish formatting? Additionally, is it possible to display certain columns in a popup window based on query parameters using jQuery or CSS? <html&g ...

How to dynamically assign width to elements in a v-for loop in Vue.JS

I am working with HTML code that looks like this: <div v-for="(s, k) in statistics" v-bind:key="s.id" class="single-stat"> <div class="stats"> { ...

Discover the steps to integrating jsfiddle into my local development environment

If you want to check out the code for this example, head over to jsfiddle at this link. And below is a snippet of the HTML file: <!DOCTYPE html> <html> <head> <script src="http://www.jacklmoore.com/colorbox/jquery.colorbox.js" type= ...

What is the best way to assign a default value in a select dropdown menu without it being a

I have a dropdown with a list of users on my web page: <select class="form-control" name="user"> <#list sbUsers as sbUser> <option value="${sbUser.login}">${sbUser.login}</option> </#list> </select> How ...

Struggling with aligning two divs side by side on an HTML page

Recently, I've been experimenting with Electron and attempting to create 2 divs side by side. Despite trying various alignment options found here, nothing seems to be working for me. Here's the code I have so far: Code body, html { hei ...

Is there a way to rigorously validate my HTML, CSS, and JavaScript files against specific standards?

Can modern browsers suppress errors in HTML, CSS, and JS sources? Is there a method to uncover all mistakes, no matter how small they may be? ...

Extract the HTML field value from an AJAX drop-down selection, rather than relying on user input

I have a field that allows users to select from a dropdown list using the following code: $(function() { $('.serial_number').live('focus.autocomplete', function() { $(this).autocomplete("/admi ...

Sorting Questions by Category

I am looking to organize a set of quiz questions into three different categories - Math, English, and Science. Is there a way to label each question within the array with its respective category and create a function that calculates scores based on these c ...

Div behaving as a radio input

I have customized radio buttons to look like buttons using JavaScript. However, on page load, both buttons automatically receive the 'active' class instead of only when they are selected. Additionally, the fadeToggle function in the if-statement ...

Click a button to show or hide text

I am attempting to create a button that will toggle text visibility from hidden using 'none' to visible using 'block'. I have tried the following code but unfortunately, it did not yield the desired outcome. <p id='demo' s ...

The width of mat-table columns remains static even with the presence of an Input field

I'm currently working on an Angular component that serves the dual purpose of displaying data and receiving data. To achieve this, I created a mat-table with input form fields and used {{element.value}} for regular data display. Each column in the tab ...