Is it acceptable to debut a full-screen iframe widget compared to an embedded one?

My current project involves integrating a custom widget into users' websites for my application. I am considering using an iframe as it seems to be the most efficient option for several reasons:

  1. Utilizing the custom framework of the application will save me time by providing pre-built code and features that are essential for the widget, such as cross-browser event handlers and prototyped objects.
  2. Avoiding CSS conflicts is easier with an iframe, eliminating the need for inline css for every dom element created.
  3. Cross-domain requests are not an issue due to prior development work utilizing jsonp for communication.

The plan currently entails creating a javascript snippet that acts as a button to load a transparent full-screen iframe on top of the window. This setup allows me complete control over the view and enables seamless integration of the widget within the parent application. Users can interact with the widget just like any other part of the website, with the ability to dismiss it by clicking outside the widget's boundaries.

The widget requires frequent server communication - making requests on load, updating views based on user interaction, and awaiting responses.

Considering these factors, would embedding the widget directly into the host's DOM and rewriting framework code be a more professional approach? While I'm willing to invest the extra effort if necessary, compatibility requirements with IE8 and the need for seamless viewing on desktop and mobile devices without intruding on the client's website are crucial considerations.

Answer №1

Discovering some insightful information from a previous post that, even though no longer active, presents compelling arguments in support of iframes.

Why developers hate iframes?

Here are a few key points that stand out:

  1. It's worth noting that many major websites like Gmail, live.com, and Facebook utilize iframes effectively for their intended purposes.
  2. In certain scenarios, such as mine, using iframes is considered preferable to prevent potential compatibility issues with external websites beyond my control. While precautions can minimize the risk of causing problems on someone else's site, using an iframe eliminates this possibility completely - which is why they were designed in the first place.
  3. Search engine optimization (SEO) is not a concern in my case. I am simply integrating a JavaScript application into remote users' websites, rather than providing searchable content.

Given these factors, I believe opting for the simpler approach is actually the more professional choice. Despite the misconception surrounding iframes due to past misuse, similar to tables, when used appropriately they serve a valuable purpose. In situations where data is best presented in a tabular format, it only makes sense to use tables (albeit styled with CSS properties like display: table-cell).

For now, I am in favor of iframes. Should my perspective evolve further along the development path of this project, I will revisit and update this answer accordingly.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Exploring JSON data with multiple nested layers of iteration

I'm currently working on a project that involves parsing through a JSON file with a complex structure. I've been attempting to extract a link to an image within the JSON data, but my current approach is resulting in an error. Below you'll fi ...

In what way can I indicate parsing "per dataset" using Chart.js?

I'm currently exploring the usage of the yAxisKey option in ChartJS while defining a dataset. However, I'm encountering difficulties in replicating this specific example from the documentation. Despite my efforts to search for issues related to y ...

Encountering an unexpected token error in Vercel during deployment, even though the code runs smoothly in the

I'm facing an issue with a SyntaxError: Unexpected token '??='. I am not sure how to resolve it, so any help would be greatly appreciated. Thank you in advance. SyntaxError: Unexpected token '??=' at wrapSafe (internal/modules ...

How can you convert a JavaScript object with nested arrays into JSON format?

I have been working with a JavaScript object that contains nested objects with associative arrays. I attempted to use the stringify function from the json2.js library, but the output did not include the arrays inside the nested objects. In my scenario, I b ...

What is the best way to search for multiple terms within a string using JavaScript?

Within my programming code, I have a string labeled S, and a collection of strings named allItems. The strings within allItems may share common "sub-words", but no element is ever an extension of another: // Example of good use where both strings contain & ...

Is it possible to integrate Laravel as the backend for an already existing HTML website template?

I recently designed an HTML template for a salon listing directory site, and while it looks great, I realize I also need a backend solution to manage listings, add advertisements, and more. Can I seamlessly integrate a Laravel-based admin panel into my c ...

Unlock the potential of Bootstrap 4 in Vue.js 2 without the need for bootstrap-vue

I'm interested in finding a way to incorporate bootstrap 4 into my vue.js 2.6 framework. Despite the abundance of tutorials available, many of them are outdated as of late 2020, or they insist on using bootstrap-vue, which introduces unwanted addition ...

ReactJS mixes up fetch URLs with another fetch_WRONG_FETCH

I have a fetch function in my Home component: export default function Home() { const { rootUrl } = useContext(UserContext); useEffect(() => { fetch(`${rootUrl}/api/products/featuredProducts`) .then((result) => result.json()) .then ...

Angular does not wait for the backend service call response in tap

Does anyone have a solution for subscribing to responses when the tap operator is used in a service? edit(status) { dataObj.val = status; // call post service with status.. this.service .update(dataObj) .pipe(takeUntil(this._n ...

Guide to setting up a Node, Express, Connect-Auth, and Backbone application architecture for server-side development

As someone who primarily works on the client-side, I have recently ventured into the realm of server-side JavaScript. My initial plan for my first Node.js application involves a server-side setup that primarily serves an empty shell along with a plethora o ...

Select a single radio button containing values that can change dynamically

<input type="radio" on-click="checkDefaultLanguage" id="checkbox" > [[names(name)]] This custom radio input field contains dynamic values and I am attempting to create a functionality where only one radio button can be selected at a time while dese ...

Utilizing AngularJS: Executing directives manually

As a newcomer to AngularJS, I am facing a challenge that requires creating a 3-step workflow: The initial step involves calling a web service that provides a list of strings like ["apple", "banana", "orange"]. Upon receiving this response, I must encap ...

When a new VueJS project is created, it failed to automatically install the necessary basic HTML files and folders

Hey there, I am completely new to Vue.js. Just recently, I installed the Vue.js/CLI and created a brand new project using vue create test. This prompted me to choose from three options: > Default ([Vue 2] babel, eslint) Default (Vue 3 Preview) ([Vue 3 ...

The computed value failing to refresh

I'm facing an interesting issue. I am currently developing a simple time tracking application. Here is the form I have created: <form class="form" @submit.prevent="saveHours"> <div class="status"> <div class="selector" v-f ...

Is there a way to dynamically modify a website's default viewport settings in a mobile browser?

When viewing a website in Landscape mode, everything looks good. However, switching to Portrait mode displays the message "Screen size not supported." I decided to test this on my desktop browser and discovered that adjusting the initial-scale:1 to initial ...

The specified type `Observable<Pet>&Observable<HttpResponse<Pet>>&Observable<HttpEvent<Pet>>` is not compatible with `Observable<HttpResponse<Pet>>`

I'm currently attempting to integrate the Angular code generated by openapi-generator with the JHipster CRUD views. While working on customizing them for the Pet entity, I encountered the following error: "Argument of type 'Observable & ...

execute a synchronous function within a promise

Recently diving into the world of JavaScript and asynchronous operations, I found myself working on a Node.js router with Express that pulls weather data from MongoDB using Mongoose. This data is collected from various sites at 15-minute intervals and proc ...

Having trouble with my bootstrap carousel not functioning properly - issue with jQuery line causing the rest of the code to disable

I've been facing some challenges with this Bootstrap slider for quite some time now. Despite my best efforts and thorough research on the forum, I just can't seem to make it function properly. Here's the code snippet in question: <!DOCTY ...

Converting numbers to strings based on locale in React Native

I have a quantity that, when using the amount.toFixed() function, produces the string "100.00". I would like this result to be formatted according to the specific locale. For example, in Italian the desired output is 100,00, while in English it should be ...

Creating multiple child processes simultaneously can be achieved by spawning five child processes in parallel

My goal is to simultaneously run five spawn commands. I am passing five hls stream urls to the loop, and these streamlink commands are meant to record the video for 5 seconds before terminating those processes. I have attempted various async methods but a ...