Is it acceptable to debut a full-screen iframe widget compared to an embedded one?

My current project involves integrating a custom widget into users' websites for my application. I am considering using an iframe as it seems to be the most efficient option for several reasons:

  1. Utilizing the custom framework of the application will save me time by providing pre-built code and features that are essential for the widget, such as cross-browser event handlers and prototyped objects.
  2. Avoiding CSS conflicts is easier with an iframe, eliminating the need for inline css for every dom element created.
  3. Cross-domain requests are not an issue due to prior development work utilizing jsonp for communication.

The plan currently entails creating a javascript snippet that acts as a button to load a transparent full-screen iframe on top of the window. This setup allows me complete control over the view and enables seamless integration of the widget within the parent application. Users can interact with the widget just like any other part of the website, with the ability to dismiss it by clicking outside the widget's boundaries.

The widget requires frequent server communication - making requests on load, updating views based on user interaction, and awaiting responses.

Considering these factors, would embedding the widget directly into the host's DOM and rewriting framework code be a more professional approach? While I'm willing to invest the extra effort if necessary, compatibility requirements with IE8 and the need for seamless viewing on desktop and mobile devices without intruding on the client's website are crucial considerations.

Answer №1

Discovering some insightful information from a previous post that, even though no longer active, presents compelling arguments in support of iframes.

Why developers hate iframes?

Here are a few key points that stand out:

  1. It's worth noting that many major websites like Gmail, live.com, and Facebook utilize iframes effectively for their intended purposes.
  2. In certain scenarios, such as mine, using iframes is considered preferable to prevent potential compatibility issues with external websites beyond my control. While precautions can minimize the risk of causing problems on someone else's site, using an iframe eliminates this possibility completely - which is why they were designed in the first place.
  3. Search engine optimization (SEO) is not a concern in my case. I am simply integrating a JavaScript application into remote users' websites, rather than providing searchable content.

Given these factors, I believe opting for the simpler approach is actually the more professional choice. Despite the misconception surrounding iframes due to past misuse, similar to tables, when used appropriately they serve a valuable purpose. In situations where data is best presented in a tabular format, it only makes sense to use tables (albeit styled with CSS properties like display: table-cell).

For now, I am in favor of iframes. Should my perspective evolve further along the development path of this project, I will revisit and update this answer accordingly.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

In TypeScript, how are angle brackets like methodName<string>() utilized?

Could someone please assist me in understanding why we use angular brackets <> in typescript? For example, I have provided some code below and would appreciate an explanation. export class HomePage { constructor(public navCtrl: NavController) { ...

Error encountered while attempting to send a delete request to MongoDB due to connection refusal

Recently, I've been diving into a Next.js tutorial that involves working with MongoDB. Everything seems to be running smoothly when testing my API endpoints with Postman. POST, GET, and DELETE requests all go through without any hiccups. However, thi ...

The parameters for Vue.js @change events are consistently returning as 0 whenever a file is uploaded by clicking on the picture

Check out my JSFiddle here:: https://jsfiddle.net/includephone/o9gpb1q8 I've encountered an issue involving the @change event on an input field. My goal is to create a carousel of images with 4 images per slide. Data Object Structure data: functio ...

Comparing getElementById with $('#element') for retrieving the length of an input field

Consider the following scenario: <input type="text" id="apple"> Why does the first code snippet work? $(document).ready(function () { alert($('#apple').val().length); }); However, why does the second code snippet not work as expecte ...

CSS text width going from left to right

I am attempting to create a text fade effect from left to right, inspired by the technique discussed in this answer. However, I would like the text to be concealed behind a transparent background div instead of the white background used in the example. I ...

attempting to eliminate on-screen buttons by hovering over the video

Is there a way to make my video play on loop like a GIF without the controls ever showing? I want it to have a seamless playback experience. Any ideas would be appreciated. P.s. Don't worry about any StackOverflow errors when running the snippet. Than ...

Display more/hide less form using div elements in a NextJS project

Looking to create a hidden block of amenities on my hotel website that can be expanded and collapsed with buttons in NextJS using tailwind-css. How can I achieve this functionality? Example 1: https://i.stack.imgur.com/BbrUj.png Example-2: https://i.stac ...

Using SVG files as properties in React from a data.js file

I have a website where I store my content in a data.js file and pass it to my components using props. Everything is working correctly, except for my .svg files. When I try to display them, they do not appear. However, if I change the extension of the image ...

Set a restriction on the Bootstrap DatePicker to only show dates within a

My application features StartDate and EndDate datepickers, and I need to implement a 30-day limit on the selection range to prevent performance issues caused by loading too much data. I'm looking for a functionality where if the user picks today as t ...

Guide on sending a request to an API and displaying the retrieved information within the same Express application

I recently developed a basic express app with API and JWT authentication. I am now attempting to enhance the app by incorporating page rendering through my existing /api/.. routes. However, I am facing challenges in this process. app.use('/', en ...

Does the TS keyof typeof <Object> rule prohibit the assignment of object.keys(<Object>)?

I'm having trouble understanding the issue with this code snippet. Here is the piece of code in question: export type SportsTypes = keyof typeof SportsIcons export const sports: SportsTypes[] = Object.keys(SportsIcons); The problem arises when I at ...

Exploring the possibilities of NodeJs by analyzing an HTML form

I'm facing an issue while evaluating an HTML Form using NodeJs and Express. Here's my JavaScript Code My aim is to manage HTML Forms in NodeJs using Express. const express = require('express'); const http = require('http'); ...

Adding an Icon to a Tab in Ant Design - A Step-by-Step Guide

Is there a way to include an icon before the title of each open tab? I am currently using the antd library for tab creation, which doesn't provide a direct option for adding icons. Here is my code snippet along with a link to the jsfiddle https://jsfi ...

Using Google Maps to trace a line showing the distance traveled

I want to create a 'distance traveled' polyline along a set route using V3 of the Google Maps API. The polyline should pass through multiple waypoints/legs. Currently, I am using the DirectionsService to draw the entire route. In addition, I a ...

What is the latest CSS browser support for the min() and max() functions in 2018?

I am considering implementing the use of the min() and max() functions in my project. I'm curious about the current browser support as of 2018. Do you think it is necessary to include the @supports at-rule? For example, I could write: .px-4-safe { ...

The specified type '{ songs: any; }' cannot be assigned to the type 'IntrinsicAttributes' in NEXTJS/Typescript

I am currently working on a straightforward script. Below is the index.tsx file for my Next.js application: import type { NextPage } from 'next' import SongsList from '../components/SongsList/SongsList' import { GetStaticProps } from & ...

What is the process for sending a token using Passport-VKontakte for social authentication?

I have integrated VK auth in my app, but in order to identify the site visitor, I need to send them a token when they click on auth vk. How can I send this token to the user using passport-vkontakte? app.get('/auth/vk', passport.authenticate(& ...

How can I stop VSC from automatically inserting "require"?

Every time I edit certain JS files in VSC, it automatically inserts "require()" calls that I then have to delete. Is there a way to stop VSC from adding these lines with "require"? Appreciate any help, Didier ...

Invoke a function from a different source in JavaScript

Below is the JS function implemented: function addMemberToLessonDirect(id) { $.ajaxSetup({ headers: { 'X-CSRF-TOKEN': $('meta[name="csrf-token"]').attr('content') } ...

Exploring the capabilities of batch updates in Firestore with the latest web version-9

I am facing issues when trying to update certain values in my firestore collection within my nuxt project. const batch = writeBatch(firestore); const data = query(collection(firestore, `notifications`, `${uid}/news`)); const querySnapshot = await ...