Does combining react-bootstrap with plain bootstrap create a negative outcome?

Currently, our team project involves a combination of react-bootstrap 1.0.0 and bootstrap 4.3.1's css+js. This has led to a divided approach within the team - some developers lean towards using react-bootstrap components while others prefer styling elements using bootstrap classes. As a result, we have ended up with two distinct styles of coding:

<ListGroup>
  <ListGroup.Item>
    Cras justo odio
  </ListGroup.Item>

vs.

<ul className="list-group">
  <li className="list-group-item">
    Cras justo odio
  </li>

What potential challenges do we foresee by maintaining this dual approach?

One immediate concern is regarding future upgrades to react-bootstrap or bootstrap. Given that react-bootstrap relies on bootstrap as a dependency, any upgrade would require concurrent updates to both libraries. Managing two migration strategies simultaneously could prove to be complex and time-consuming.

cssbootstrap-4react-bootstrap

Answer №1

When it comes to mixing Bootstrap and React, opinions may differ, but the consensus leans towards it being a detrimental idea. The concept of "just being inconsistent" does not hold up well in this case, as inconsistency can lead to various issues. Here are some key reasons why combining these two frameworks should be avoided:

  • Cross-Library Interactions - One major concern is the potential for conflict between Bootstrap, which manipulates the DOM, and React, a JavaScript UI library. This can result in unintended changes to React components by Bootstrap, akin to using jQuery on React elements. While React Bootstrap was designed to mimic Bootstrap using rebuilt JS implementation, there is still a risk of targeting shared class names.
  • Speed/Performance - Including both Bootstrap and React Bootstrap introduces redundant dependencies that serve similar purposes. Eliminating one of them can help save unnecessary bytes and optimize performance.
  • Maintainability - Updating an application that employs both frameworks requires specific expertise or additional training. Even if developers are familiar with both styles, switching back and forth between them can be confusing and cumbersome.
  • Expectability - Determining which parts of the application use Bootstrap versus React Bootstrap can be challenging. Establishing consistency throughout the entire project simplifies decision-making and development processes for all team members.
  • Hiring/Training - In a dynamic team environment, turnover is inevitable. Introducing dual framework usage adds complexity to the hiring and training process when new developers need to understand and work with both Bootstrap and React Bootstrap.

Answer №2

When using React-Bootstrap components alongside JSX with Bootstrap classes, both will be styled by the same CSS file. React-Bootstrap does not come with its own styles, so you must incorporate Bootstrap's CSS into your project. This eliminates the need for a double migration as updates or replacements to the stylesheet will impact both sets of code.

In addition, React-Bootstrap utilizes its own reimplementation of Bootstrap's JavaScript instead of directly relying on Bootstrap's JS. This means that integrating Bootstrap's JavaScript should not interfere with the functionality of React-Bootstrap components. However, if you wish to utilize Bootstrap's JavaScript features in your code, you will need to include them separately.

For more information, visit:

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Javascript's second element does not trigger a click event with similar behavior

I'm currently facing an issue with displaying and hiding notification elements based on user interaction. My goal is to have multiple popup elements appear when the page loads. Then, when a user clicks the ".alert-close" element within one of the popu ...

javascriptjqueryhtmlcss

CSS - Desiring a border with three layers

Here is the CSS code I am using: border: 2px solid #00ff60; outline: 1px solid #000; outline-offset: 0px; This is how it looks: https://i.sstatic.net/SuvU1.png Is there a way to modify it so that it includes an inner black border, similar to the one at ...

css

React animation failing to render underline animation

After tinkering with the underline animation while scrolling down on Codepen using Javascript, I successfully implemented it. You can check out the working version on Codepen. This animation utilizes Intersection Observer and a generated svg for the underl ...

javascriptcssreactjstypescriptmaterial-ui

Display SVG at full size without any distortion

How can I make the SVG image 100% by 100% without scaling? I want the image to be centered on the page both horizontally and vertically. The challenge is that I also want to display the areas outside of the SVG artboard, so using CSS to center it won&apos ...

javascriptjqueryhtmlcsssvg

Displaying multiple images in a Django modal

I've been working on getting Django to show images in a modal popup, but I'm running into an issue. When I have multiple images, only the first one is displayed in the modal popup. The scaled-down images used as buttons show the correct images, s ...

djangodjango-templatesbootstrap-4bootstrap-modal

Absolute positioning causes a 100% height container to be displaced from the IE viewport

While my code works seamlessly in Firefox and Safari, Internet Explorer presents a challenge I cannot seem to solve. The Problem: In non-IE browsers, the container displays properly with space around the edges of the viewport. However, in IE, the containe ...

htmlcssinternet-explorerlayout

CSS-Styled Vertical Timeline

I have been working on creating a vertical timeline with icons embedded within it. I initially used this as a reference point. I was able to achieve the desired layout by adding extra spans inside the div. However, the end result appears somewhat cluttere ...

htmlcss

Combining divs with identical values in Angular

I am working on creating my very own custom Calendar. Take a look at the full example of my component here I need help figuring out how to combine week divs that share the same value {{day.weekNumber}} so that there is only one div for each shared value, ...

htmlcssangular

Close the fullscreen modal automatically when clicking anywhere inside

Hey there, I'm facing an issue with a button that I want to trigger a full-screen section containing some inputs. I attempted to use Bootstrap's full-screen modal for this purpose, but encountered some challenges. When I clicked anywhere on the ...

javascripthtmlcssbootstrap-4bootstrap-modal

Finding out the exact number of pixels a user will scroll when using the mouse wheel in Javascript

Is there a way to calculate the number of pixels that will be moved by the vertical scroll bar when a user scrolls using the mouse wheel in JavaScript? In my situation, the user's scrolling will result in an offsetTop change between 200px to 1000px, ...

javascripthtmlcssreactjsangular

Simple ways to conceal the style of the underline for disabled input fields

When customizing the appearance of an HTML element such as paper-input and disabled, a dotted underline style is automatically applied. https://i.sstatic.net/utwHg.png To modify the disabled styles, you can do the following: paper-input { --paper-input ...

cssinputpolymerdisabled-inputtext-decorations

Erase the border around the color selection field

Here's a demonstration: http://jsfiddle.net/WpJRk/ I've incorporated a color picker into my webpage using the new input type "color": <input type="color"> However, I've noticed that there is an unwanted black border within the eleme ...

htmlcssgoogle-chrometwitter-bootstrap

Adjusting height in CSS can be done dynamically based on the content within

Currently, I am working on a project where I need the submenu to adjust based on content. The issue is that right now, the submenu has a fixed capacity of 4 items. For example, when you click on 'sale', it displays 4 submenu items perfectly. Howe ...

htmlcss

Translate3d increases the whitespace towards the end of the page

After implementing a smooth scroll on my webpage using transform translate3d, I encountered an issue. The translate3d function seems to be adding extra space at the end of the document, as illustrated here: https://codepen.io/anon/pen/WEpLGE I suspect the ...

javascriptcss

Creating a cohesive design by ensuring buttons match the appearance of other elements, and vice versa

During the process of building a website, I encountered a challenge in making buttons work seamlessly with other elements to ensure uniformity in appearance. This issue often arises in menus, where some buttons are functional while others are simply li ...

htmlcss

Interactive Map Using HTML5, CSS, and JQuery

As someone venturing into the world of web front end development, I am curious about the process of mapping an image so that specific functions can be triggered by pressing different parts. In this case, the shapes will be irregular (such as a map of Europ ...

jqueryhtmlimagecssmapping

Having trouble getting the jQuery toggle function to work properly with div elements

I'm struggling with some divs that are not behaving as expected. When I click the button, it opens and changes the text to "Collapse", but when I click it again, it doesn't change the text back to "Find Support". Additionally, if I click on a dif ...

jqueryhtmlcss

Upgrading from Vuetify 2 to 3 involves replacing the deprecated styles like .v-application, rounded, and flat with

I need help with upgrading from Vuetify/Vue 2 to Vue 3. I don't have much experience in front-end development, but I am responsible for updating some old code to keep things running smoothly. The migration guide is not very clear and assumes a certain ...

cssvue.jsvuejs3vuetify.jsvuetifyjs3

What is the source of this additional space?

To view my Codepen project, check out this link: http://codepen.io/leongaban/pen/aFJfs I have noticed that the spacing issue is related to the .email-tip-icon and the tip-message classes. When I remove them, the extra space disappears. Even though both th ...

htmlcsspositionspacing

Issue with parallax scroll feature on Mobile Safari not functioning as expected

I created a JavaScript code for parallax scrolling on an image at the top of a webpage. The code functions perfectly on Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer, Opera, and Safari on desktop. However, when I tested it on Safari on my iPad, the parallax effect wa ...

javascriptjqueryioscssmobile-safari