Differences in React projects utilizing materialize-css compared to those using react-toolbox or material-ui

Is there a difference in technical benefits or code reliability when directly using material-css in JSX versus utilizing JSX specific libraries like material-ui or react-toolbox? Conversely, could using JSX libraries like material-ui or react-toolbox provide performance enhancements, improved reliability, or other measurable advantages compared to incorporating materialize-css code directly into JSX?

When creating React components, I have the option to include materialize-css directly in my JSX:

<div className="row">
    <div className="blue lighten-5 col s12 m1 l1">1</div>
</div>
<a className="waves-effect waves-light btn">Stuff</a>

Alternatively, I can choose to use a JSX specific library like material-ui:

import RaisedButton from 'material-ui/RaisedButton';
...
<RaisedButton label="Submit" type="submit" primary={true} style={style}/>

This inquiry is not about personal preference of libraries or distinguishing between output differences. The question at hand is: are there technical advantages or increased reliabilities by opting for material-ui or similar JSX libraries as opposed to inserting materialize-css code directly into JSX? If there are potential benefits or risks involved, what are they? What precautions should be taken into consideration?

Answer №1

When it comes to buttons, the difference may seem insignificant, which could explain why you're not noticing the optimal path.

However, where Material-UI truly shines is in its functional components. The DatePicker, AutoComplete, and Tabs stand out as prime examples of this. MUI, being built on react, allows for these functional elements to be easily customized using your own events and handlers, a feat that raw css simply cannot achieve.

In addition, the MUI library boasts a significantly larger collection compared to the materialize library.

Answer №2

For those considering the materialcss approach, I highly recommend checking out react-materialize.

While using material style goes beyond just applying stylesheets, integrating JS can streamline the process and offer the benefits of a popular library such as testing, bug fixes, and new features.

One advantage is the ability to create custom components based on materialize while maintaining the overall look and feel of react-materialize components.

Personally, I prefer Material-UI for quickly developing sleek modern apps.

Best of luck with your projects!

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Building secure routes in React with NextJS

Objective : My goal is to automatically redirect a user who is logged in back to the home page if they try to manually access the /auth/signin route. Signin page/component : const Signin = ({ currentUser }) => { const [email, setEmail] = useState ...

Encountering a 500 server error while trying to send an email using SendGrid in conjunction

Seeking help on integrating an email capture form into a NextJS site by following this tutorial: Simplified the form to only include the email field. The content of my api/contact.js file is as follows: const mail = require('@sendgrid/mail'); ...

Does the content from an AJAX request get loaded if you flush it using ob_flush()?

Imagine this scenario, where we are making an AJAX request and inserting the result inside a div with the id of "result". On the backend, the script is using ob_flush() to send the header but not terminating the request until it's explicitly terminat ...

What is the best way to nest _app.js within several providers?

Is there a way to wrap my top-level page _app.js in both Redux provider and Next-auth provider? Currently, I have already wrapped it in the Next-auth provider like this: import React from "react" import { Provider } from 'next-auth/client&ap ...

retrieve information from an array of objects that include promises

Within my react application, I am faced with the task of retrieving email and name data for various user IDs from separate API endpoints. To achieve this, I follow these steps: const promises = ids.map( id => ( {email: axios.get(`blabla/${id}/email ...

An issue with jQuery and LESS causing stylesheets to update only once

Struggling with updating a custom CSS href - everything works perfectly the first time, but subsequent updates do not reflect any changes on the page. Even though I can see the href updating in Chrome debugger and there are no errors being thrown by LESS, ...

Setting up the InMemoryCache in Vue ApolloConfiguring the InMemoryCache

I've set up vue-apollo following the instructions in the apollo.config.js file from this guide: (I'm using VSCode). Now, I want to configure the InMemoryCache to exclude the typeName (addTypename: false) like it's explained here: https://w ...

"Revolutionizing React with Redux in the digital age

There was an issue while trying to write the file 'c:\Windows\System32\sony\src\asad.js'. The error message states: NoPermissions (FileSystemError): Error: EPERM: operation not permitted, open 'c:\Windows\S ...

Attempting to iterate over an array and utilize a foreach loop to return several sets of data

In my original code, getProductInfo took two parameters (res, sku). However, I now want to pass a set object containing SKU numbers and for each SKU, send the data using res.send. const activeProductBank = new Set([6401728, 6430161, 6359222, 6368084]); g ...

Tips for showcasing heading and paragraph elements side by side in css?

I have a block of HTML code that includes a heading and two paragraphs: <div class="inter"> <h4>Note</h4> <p>To add/remove a dependent or to modify your spouse's insurer information, go to the My Life Events section and foll ...

The Bootstrap row fails to align elements side by side as intended

I'm trying to arrange elements in my navigation menu side by side, so I decided to use the row class from Bootstrap 5.0. However, they are still stacking on top of each other. I am currently working on a Flask project and using Jinja to some extent. ...

The mapStateToProps value is one keystroke delayed compared to the getState() value

Currently, I am implementing redux's connect() method on my App.js file and then passing a dispatcher down to a child component. The child component also receives the state variable as a prop. The problem I am encountering is that when logging the st ...

Tips for speeding up page loading when using the same image multiple times on a page

Is it possible to utilize a JavaScript Image object? If yes, could you provide an illustrative example? And is it feasible to achieve this with jQuery? ...

Creating a mandatory and meaningful text input in Angular 2 is essential for a

I am trying to ensure that a text material input in my app is mandatory, with a message like "Please enter issue description." However, I have noticed that users can bypass this by entering spaces or meaningless characters like "xxx." Is there an npm pac ...

What strategies can I implement to keep my Nextjs App logged in?

What steps can I take to keep regular users from needing to log in every time they visit the website in a NextJs (ReactJs) environment? ...

What is the best way to create a universal variable that can be accessed across all routes in an Express/

Exploring the world of nodejs and express, I have turned to the Parse API for my backend database needs. At the moment, I have an ajax post triggered on page load to one of my routers /getuser, which retrieves the current user if they are logged in. I am ...

Determine the full location information with the help of Google Maps SDK without the need

My current challenge involves dealing with a list of unformatted and incorrectly written addresses. I am seeking a way to iterate through these flawed strings and generate more organized and accurate addresses using one of the many Google Maps SDKs availa ...

Creating a CSS grid layout with dual columns to dynamically adjust and accommodate two items in each row

I am attempting to create this layout using CSS grid: The goal is to have an input and a textarea. The textarea should be of the size of 2 inputs. If there is already a textarea in the previous column, the next column should accommodate 2 inputs. The numb ...

Expanding a class functionality by incorporating a method through .prototype

My goal is to define a class called "User" and then add a method to the class using the "prototype" keyword. I want the method "who_auto" to be accessible to all future instances of "User". When testing this code in JSFiddle, I encountered the error messa ...

Error message in Material-UI TextField not displaying when state is updated using Object.assign technique

Currently, I am facing an issue with validating a login form and displaying errors dynamically. These errors are passed as props from the child component. The problem arises when I set the errors object using Object.assign - the errorText does not show up ...